Brazil win against Chile despite scratchy performance

If not for Luiz Henrique's crucial goal in the 88th minute, Friday’s sports headlines would almost certainly be dominated by Brazil's near-exclusion from the group of six South American teams poised to qualify directly for the World Cup. A draw in Chile would have plunged the Seleçao into an ignominious position, trailing even Bolivia and level on points with Venezuela, languishing in seventh—a spot that would force them into the playoffs. Such a scenario would be nothing short of a national embarrassment.

But Henrique’s 2-1 strike in Santiago was more than just a victory; it was a momentary reprieve for a team enduring its worst-ever start to a World Cup qualifying campaign. Despite their struggles, Brazil walked away not only with three critical points but also a fleeting respite from the storm of criticism swirling around them.

For the better part of two years, Brazil's performances have teetered on the edge of mediocrity. The footballing giant has lost its former fluency and spark, still searching for answers and coherence. There’s much left to rebuild and correct, but those tasks seem far more achievable when the team isn't labouring under the weight of public scrutiny.

Despite the victory, the match laid bare the familiar frustrations. Brazil played without the elegance once synonymous with its name, stumbling through the same tactical quagmires that plagued their Copa America run and prior qualifying rounds. And yet, within the struggles, there were glimmers of promise - faint, but discernible.

What cannot be dismissed is the team’s resilience. After conceding just 86 seconds into the game, Brazil managed to shake off the early shock, displaying an admirable resolve to claw their way back. Away from home, under the shadows of hostile Chilean stands, they wrestled control of the game, dominating possession with nearly 70% of the ball. Goalkeeper Ederson, in fact, had little to do throughout the match.

While offensively improved compared to their dismal displays against Ecuador and Paraguay in September, the team’s attack remains a work in progress. With Savinho anchored on the right and Rodrygo and Raphinha roaming the wings, the team relied heavily on the wide play, largely due to its struggles in the central buildup. The midfield, with André and Lucas Paqueta at its core, suffered from imprecision, and the gap between defence and attack yawned wide, a structural flaw in Dorival Junior’s evolving tactical setup. His formation, shifting between a 3-2-5 during possession and a 4-4-2 in defence, is still far from perfect.

On the bright side, the debuts of left-back Abner and forward Igor Jesus offered a sense of possibility. Abner showed initiative, stretching the Chilean defence with his wide passes, while Igor Jesus brought physicality upfront that Brazil’s other forwards, including the highly touted Endrick, have yet to demonstrate. Igor’s positioning and precise header levelled the match just before halftime, a fitting introduction for a player offering a different dimension to Brazil's attack.

It’s far too early to draw conclusions about these newcomers, but their promise is a breath of fresh air for a team in need of solutions in pivotal areas.

Yet, for every sign of progress, old wounds remain. Defensive lapses, typified by Danilo’s ineffectiveness both at the back and in attack, coupled with technical errors, continue to disrupt Brazil’s rhythm. These issues linger, nagging reminders of the work still ahead for Dorival Junior and his squad.

Without the victory, the mounting pressure could have easily turned Brazil’s rebuilding process into a battle for survival. Now, at least, they have room to breathe.

Thank You

Faisal Caesar