Few Test matches in cricket’s long and storied history have been shorter, but none have so completely shattered the credibility of officials and administrators as the opening game of the 1997-98 series between the West Indies and England at Sabina Park. What unfolded that day was not merely a sporting debacle but a parable of misjudgment, denial, and an almost Shakespearean tragedy of hubris.
For just over an hour, as England’s physio made his desperate pilgrimages to the middle, the pitch—a capricious, cracked, and crumbling surface—dictated the terms. It was not cricket; it was survival. And then, with an inevitability that had been written long before the first ball was bowled, the umpires conferred with the captains and took the extraordinary step of abandoning the match.
The real question, of course, was whether it should ever have begun.
A Foretold Disaster
Three months before the first Test, the Sabina Park square had been dug up and relaid—a process that, in the best of circumstances, demands time, care, and a deep understanding of soil science. Instead, the pitch was hurried into existence, a patchwork of uncertainty, its flaws barely concealed beneath an ill-fitting veneer of optimism. Groundsman Charlie Joseph and George Prescod, the Jamaican board’s chief executive, remained steadfast in their assurances. It would be ready. It would hold together. It would play true.
But when the England squad arrived, their first sight of the surface evoked dismay. The cracks were not hairline fractures but gaping wounds. The colour was an ominous reddish-orange as if the earth itself bore signs of some ancient battle. The former England seamer-turned-journalist Mike Selvey, writing for The Guardian, painted a grim picture:
"It would appear the pitch was replaced by a cowboy gang of tarmac layers of the sort who will skim your drive with a quarter inch of blackstuff in return for ready money."
Alan Lee, in The Times, was equally damning:
"Most of the tour party have never seen a pitch quite like this. It is arid, cracked, and corrugated. The kindest of assessments would conclude that the recent relaying programme was hideously mistimed."
Even the untrained eye could sense impending catastrophe. A former West Indian player, speaking anonymously, hinted at conspiracy. The pitch had been deliberately left in disrepair, he suggested. "It’s going to be lively," he warned. "It could come down to the survival of the bravest."
The players, however, had no choice but to trust the officials. The game would go on.
The Unequal Contest Between Bat and Earth
At the toss, Mike Atherton—perhaps less choosing to bat than refusing to bowl on such a surface—walked out with Mark Butcher to face the might of Courtney Walsh and Curtly Ambrose. What followed was not cricket but a grim exercise in endurance.
The pitch behaved like an unpredictable beast, growling one moment and lashing out the next. One ball flew over Atherton’s shoulder; another, landing in roughly the same area, scuttled past his ankles. Within minutes, Butcher—who had only been drafted into the side that morning—was dismissed in a surreal fashion. A short delivery reared up at him like a striking cobra, forcing an involuntary fend. The ball ballooned into the air, and as he walked back, dazed, his teammate Adam Hollioake simply laughed.
It was a laughter of disbelief, of absurdity, of men caught in a situation so ridiculous that humour became the only available coping mechanism.
As wickets tumbled, the England dressing room became a theatre of hushed alarm. John Crawley chain-smoked, muttering: "Jesus, someone's going to get killed out there." When a short ball from Ambrose flew past Graham Thorpe’s helmet and over the wicketkeeper’s head for four byes, Crawley erupted: "For f*s sake… this is ridiculous!" Nervous laughter spread through the dressing room like an uncontrollable contagion.
A Game That Could Not Go On
Alec Stewart, England’s wicketkeeper-batsman, found himself not merely battling the West Indian attack but also negotiating the very surface on which the sport was meant to be played. As he stood mid-pitch, staring at the crater-like divots left by the bouncing ball, Ambrose shrugged helplessly.
"There’s nothing I can do about it," the great fast bowler admitted.
When another vicious delivery struck Thorpe’s elbow, Stewart saw his opportunity. "Stay down," he told Thorpe. The longer the physio stayed on the field, the greater the likelihood that sanity would prevail.
By then, Barry Jarman, the match referee, had seen enough. The umpires—Steve Bucknor and Srinivas Venkataraghavan—called the captains together. Brian Lara, leading the West Indies for the first time, was acutely aware of his precarious position with Caribbean fans.
"Shit, you'll have to do it," he told Atherton. "It's my first game as captain, and they already hate me here."
The decision was inevitable. The match was abandoned.
The Fallout
The scene that followed was one of profound anti-climax. The stadium emptied in stunned silence. The English contingent—players, journalists, and fans—stood in muted frustration. Bob Bennett, England’s manager, initially instructed his team not to comment on the pitch. But the absurdity of that request became apparent.
"What do you want us to do," quipped Hollioake, "sing its praises?"
Meanwhile, Joseph, the groundsman, was inconsolable. "I am crying tears and blood," he admitted. "People have come from England just to watch this match. My heart goes out to them."
The Caribbean press was unforgiving. The Jamaica Gleaner thundered:
"The pitch should now be dug up, and those directly responsible for this travesty of a Test pitch should be buried in the same hole."
The shame, the embarrassment, and the damage to Jamaica’s cricketing reputation were profound.
The Epilogue: Lessons and Legacy
In the aftermath, the Jamaican Cricket Association acted swiftly, uprooting the square and experimenting with different clay compositions until they arrived at a stable solution. A year later, when Australia visited, Steve Waugh—never one to dish out empty compliments—praised the new surface.
Yet the scars of that abandoned Test ran deeper than mere embarrassment. It was a reminder that cricket, for all its romanticism, is also an enterprise that demands responsibility. A game that has seen bodyline, underarm bowling, and the occasional riot had now witnessed its most infamous abdication of duty—not by players, but by those entrusted with the integrity of the sport.
And for those who were there that day, Sabina Park would never again be just another cricket ground. It would remain a monument to folly, a cautionary tale of what happens when arrogance meets unpreparedness, and when a pitch—meant to be a stage—becomes an executioner.
Thank You
Faisal Caesar
No comments:
Post a Comment