The Manchester rain arrived not as a gentle drizzle but as a sly accomplice, swooping in late enough to spare England the full humiliation of defeat, yet too late to rescue selectors - Graham Gooch and Mike Gatting from their public beheading. At Lord MacLaurin’s fourth-day dinner — nominally a toast to incoming coach Duncan Fletcher and the small junta charged with shepherding England into the next millennium — the mood was less congratulatory, more conspiratorial.
Official denials dismissed the notion of a “crisis meeting,” but the decision was sealed: Gooch and Gatting would choose no more England sides. Logic demanded that Fletcher and touring captain Nasser Hussain shape the coming winter’s South African expedition. The reasoning was sound. The timing was merciless.
An Old Guard’s Last Stand
The axe fell in the shadow of the Old Trafford squad announcement — a list that reeked of safety-first selection. Michael Atherton with his aching back, Graeme Hick with his brittle temperament, and 35-year-old Peter Such returned as if youth were a dangerous indulgence. Chris Silverwood, a rare nod to the future, was quietly sent home before the serious business began. Habib was jettisoned after two Tests; Allan Mullally sacrificed for an extra spinner.
And then, fate dealt another twist. Nasser Hussain’s broken finger ruled him out, and into the breach stepped Mark Butcher — the second-youngest in the XI, armed with little more than a stand-in captaincy stint at Surrey.
He inherited not just a team but a stage set for failure: a relaid pitch, gifted to Old Trafford against local judgment, ripened into a batting nightmare under an uncharacteristically mischievous Manchester sun.
The Strokeless Surrender
Butcher won the toss and chose to bat. It was an act of misplaced optimism. The pitch was a pudding: low bounce, unreliable pace, a slow-burn death for shot-making. England’s response was a collective retreat. Butcher fell early, leaving Atherton to wall himself behind defensive strokes. His two-and-a-quarter-hour crawl to 11 was tactical, he claimed — an effort to tire Cairns and Nash. The rain, obligingly for New Zealand, came to refresh them instead.
Hick briefly threatened to change the tone with three boundaries, then collapsed into an LBW. Mark Ramprakash crafted an unbeaten 69 — his highest home Test score — marooned amid a tail that could not push the total beyond 199. Such, in a masterpiece of negative theatre, endured 72 minutes without scoring, the second-longest duck in Test history, drawing a standing ovation from a crowd grateful for anything resembling entertainment.
The Kiwi Feast
If England were parsimonious, New Zealand were decadent. Their 496 for nine was not only imposing but stylish, a rebuttal to accusations of colourlessness. Matthew Bell’s 83 — more than doubling his career tally — was a masterclass in patient growth. Nathan Astle’s 101 and Craig McMillan’s unbeaten 107 brimmed with enterprise and boundary-hitting audacity. Cairns joined the spree. Every one of the eleven had a first-class hundred; every one seemed intent on proving it. England’s bowlers — each conceding over 100 runs — aged before our eyes.
A Flicker Before the Deluge
Stephen Fleming’s declaration left England with five sessions to survive. Butcher faltered again, but Atherton and Alec Stewart found some of their old assurance, adding 99. Atherton fell two short of a fifty, victim to umpire David Shepherd’s misread sweep that struck his arm, not his bat. The rain returned, blotting out the rest of the day. On the final afternoon, Stewart’s lively 83 was truncated by another weather front, the final curtain in a match where meteorology proved England’s most effective ally.
The Reckoning Deferred
For New Zealand, it was a week of renewal and rebuttal, their cricket reborn in colour and confidence. For England, salvation arrived in the wind and rain — a reprieve misread as resilience. The storm clouds over Old Trafford lifted, but the larger weather system — the one swirling over English cricket’s governance, selection, and philosophy — showed no sign of clearing.
No comments:
Post a Comment