On the night many at Real Madrid expected to sack him, Xabi Alonso walked into the Bernabéu knowing he was managing not just a football match, but a verdict. He watched his battered, makeshift team rise against Manchester City with spirit and defiance—only to fall again. When the final whistle arrived, the whistles from the stands followed. Alonso embraced Pep Guardiola, disappeared down the tunnel without a backward glance, and left behind the same question that has hung over this club all season: Is this enough to save him?
A Coach on the Edge, A Team Showing Life
Six injured defenders. No Camavinga. No Militão, Carvajal, Mendy, Alaba, or Alexander-Arnold. Kylian Mbappé, the supposed face of a new era, scratched at the last minute with an ankle issue. Four Castilla players on the bench. Fede Valverde reinvented himself as a right-back and captain. Gonzalo García pushed into the XI. Dani Ceballos, long forgotten, suddenly became a creative hub.
It was not a lineup; it was a plea.
And yet, Madrid started with something they have lacked for weeks: urgency. Vinícius demanded noise from the Bernabéu, Rodrygo rediscovered a pulse with his first goal in 33 games, and the players ran—truly ran—for their coach. Their early intensity forced City into errors. For 25 minutes, it looked like Real Madrid again.
Rodrygo’s goal was more than a finish—it was a statement. He ran straight to Alonso, embracing him publicly at one of the most precarious moments in the coach’s brief tenure.
“It’s a complicated moment for him too,” Rodrygo said, “and I wanted to show we are united.”
But unity does not always bring salvation.
Madrid’s Fragility Returns
If Madrid had rediscovered their heartbeat, they had not repaired their flaws. A scrambled corner, then Antonio Rüdiger’s catastrophic decision to lunge at Erling Haaland in the box, flipped the night upside down. Haaland does not miss those penalties. Courtois briefly preserved dignity with a miraculous double save, but the damage was done.
In the second half, Manchester City began to play like Manchester City. Jérémy Doku tore at Madrid’s patched-together defence. Madrid, unable to build sustained attacks without chaos, reverted to hopeful rushes forward. The whistles returned. So did the anxiety.
Yet Madrid still nearly clawed back the draw:
– Tchouaméni heading inches wide
– Vinícius missing an empty net
– Rodrygo flashing a shot just over
– And Endrick, forgotten all season, rattling the crossbar in despair
Fine margins. Another night where courage was undeniable, but the outcome was irreversible.
Pep’s Unfiltered Advice—and the Reality
Before this first managerial meeting between student and mentor, Guardiola was asked what advice he’d give Alonso. His answer was blunt, vulgar, and true:
“Que mee con la suya.” – Piss with your own penis. Do it your own way.
But could Alonso truly do that?
With seven key players unavailable, his choices were more constrained than conviction. And yet, there were signs of a coach trying to reshape a broken team—Ceballos as a playmaker, Valverde as captain, Vinícius moved centrally to re-centre the attack, Rodrygo restored to confidence.
The football wasn’t perfect, but it was purposeful. The question is whether it came too late.
The Boardroom: Suspended Sentence, Uncertain Future
Last Sunday night, after a run of two wins in seven matches, sections of Madrid’s hierarchy—never known for patience—were ready to dismiss Alonso. His reprieve was conditional: show life against City, show progress, and show something.
He did.
But Madrid still lost. And in a club where performances matter but results dictate survival, that distinction is rarely enough.
As Alonso said afterwards, “This bad moment will pass.”
The problem is that Real Madrid coaches aren’t always given time to wait for the passing.
The Verdict: Improvement, Yes. Salvation, Uncertain.
Madrid were better. Much better.
They competed, not capitulated. They showed spirit, unity, and structure that had been missing for weeks. The fans felt it. The players felt it. Even Guardiola felt it.
But—and this is the painful truth—Real Madrid measure progress with comebacks, not consolation. Near-misses do not absolve defeats. Improving while losing is still losing.
Alonso is not blameless either. His substitutions were questionable; Gonzalo García should have stayed on longer, Vinícius should have come off earlier. Tactical bravery is one thing; managerial stubbornness is another. Alonso occasionally shoots himself in the foot—and on nights like this, every mistake echoes louder.
Final Opinion: Madrid Showed Life, But the Coach’s Future Still Hangs by a Thread
This match proved two things at once:
1. Xabi Alonso’s Madrid is still fighting.
2. Real Madrid are still falling short.
The Bernabéu saw signs of a team trying to rise again, but signs cannot replace points. The club must now decide whether this performance represents a foundation—or a farewell.
If the standard is improved, Alonso stays.
If the standard is results, he may already be gone in all but name.
As harsh as it sounds, Madrid are a club that does not wait for better days.
And right now, Xabi Alonso’s future depends on whether the people who run this club believe that what they saw was a beginning—or just the last spark before the lights go out.


















