The Ballon d’Or Debate: A Question of Merit and Prestige

The Ballon d’Or, conceived by the visionary Gabriel Hanot and awarded by *France Football*, has long been regarded as one of football’s most prestigious honours. Since its inception in 1956, the award has evolved, expanding its eligibility criteria from European players to all players in European clubs in 1995, and eventually to global recognition in 2007. While its illustrious history and rigorous voting process—now involving journalists, national team coaches, and captains—have cemented its reputation, the 2019 award sparked controversy, casting a shadow on its credibility. 

A Legacy of Excellence 

The Ballon d’Or is more than just an accolade; it is a symbol of excellence, awarded to players who define footballing greatness in a given season. Over the decades, it has celebrated legends who have delivered when it mattered most—on both club and international stages. Yet, as with any award, its history is not without contention. The 2019 Ballon d’Or, awarded to Lionel Messi, reignited debates about fairness and the criteria for selecting the best player in the world. 

The Case Against Lionel Messi 

Lionel Messi, often hailed as one of the greatest players of all time, undoubtedly possesses an unparalleled skill set. His ability to mesmerize with the ball at his feet and his knack for producing moments of magic are unmatched. However, the Ballon d’Or is awarded for a specific season’s performance, and Messi’s 2018–19 campaign fell short of the standards typically associated with this honour. 

Club Performance: A Season of Contradictions 

At the club level, Messi’s Barcelona won La Liga, but their season was marred by a catastrophic collapse in the UEFA Champions League. After a commanding 3-0 first-leg victory against Liverpool in the semifinals, Barcelona capitulated at Anfield, losing 4-0 in one of the most shocking comebacks in football history. Messi, despite his brilliance in the earlier stages, failed to inspire his team when it mattered most. 

Critics argue that Messi’s success in La Liga alone does not justify the award. The Champions League, widely regarded as the pinnacle of club football, saw him falter under pressure. Since Neymar’s departure, Messi has struggled to replicate the European dominance Barcelona once enjoyed, raising questions about his ability to lead the team in the post-Xavi and Iniesta era. 

International Performance: A Familiar Struggle 

In the national colours of Argentina, Messi’s woes continued. The 2019 Copa América was another missed opportunity. Argentina’s campaign ended in disappointment, with Messi receiving a red card in the third-place play-off against Chile. His post-match comments blaming officials for Argentina’s failure did little to endear him to neutrals, especially given the country’s controversial footballing history. 

The Overlooked Contenders 

Virgil van Dijk: The Defensive Maestro 

Virgil van Dijk’s 2018–19 season was nothing short of extraordinary. The Dutch defender was the cornerstone of Liverpool’s UEFA Champions League triumph, leading a backline that conceded just 22 goals in the Premier League. His unmatched defensive prowess saw him go an entire season without being dribbled past, a feat that underscored his dominance. 

Van Dijk’s contributions extended beyond defence; he provided crucial goals and assists, stepping up in key moments for both club and country. As the runner-up in the UEFA Nations League with the Netherlands, Van Dijk demonstrated his ability to shine on the international stage. Many argue that his all-encompassing impact deserved the Ballon d’Or, making him the most deserving defender since Fabio Cannavaro in 2006. 

Cristiano Ronaldo: The Eternal Competitor 

Cristiano Ronaldo, Messi’s perennial rival, also had a compelling case. Leading Juventus to the Serie A title and Portugal to the inaugural UEFA Nations League crown, Ronaldo showcased his enduring ability to deliver at the highest level. His goal-scoring exploits, both domestically and internationally, surpassed Messi’s, with 49 goals in 2019 compared to Messi’s 45. 

Alisson Becker: The Guardian of Glory 

Alisson Becker’s role in Liverpool’s success cannot be overstated. As the winner of the Champions League, Copa América, and multiple individual awards for goalkeeping, Alisson was the backbone of every team he represented. Yet, like many goalkeepers before him, his contributions were undervalued in the Ballon d’Or voting—a recurring theme that has seen legends like Manuel Neuer and Iker Casillas overlooked in the past. 

The Verdict 

The 2019 Ballon d’Or decision has divided the footballing world. While Messi’s brilliance is undeniable, his performances in the 2018–19 season did not align with the award’s criteria. The snub of Van Dijk, Ronaldo, and Alisson raises questions about the voting process and the weight given to individual versus team achievements. 

The Ballon d’Or’s prestige lies in its ability to honour the best performer of the year, but when the award appears to prioritize reputation over results, its credibility suffers. Football fans, especially neutrals, expect fairness and consistency. For many, the 2019 Ballon d’Or was a missed opportunity to celebrate the true standout performers of the season. 

In the end, the Ballon d’Or remains a symbol of excellence, but its legacy depends on the integrity of its decisions. As football evolves, so too must the criteria and transparency of its most coveted awards.

Thank You

Faisal Caesar 

David Warner’s Redemption: A Triple Hundred for the Ages

Four years ago, a fan on Twitter cheekily asked David Warner to score a triple hundred in Test cricket. Warner’s response, laced with self-awareness, was simple: “Have you seen my patience haha.” The statement encapsulated Warner’s reputation—a batsman known for his explosive, whirlwind hundreds rather than the composed, methodical innings often associated with the likes of Steve Smith. His double century at the WACA in 2015 was an exception, a fleeting glimpse of what could be if Warner tempered his aggression with patience. 

Fast forward to 2019, and Warner returned to the narrative, this time armed with a more refined approach. Against an under-strength Pakistani bowling attack at the Adelaide Oval, Warner not only silenced his doubters but etched his name into the annals of cricketing history with an unbeaten 335. 

A Lesson in Patience and Precision 

Warner’s journey to this milestone was a study in evolution. Known for his tendency to dominate bowlers with quick scoring, Warner displayed an uncharacteristic restraint in Adelaide. It wasn’t about run-a-ball flamboyance; it was about occupying the crease, building an innings, and capitalizing on a Pakistani side that seemed bereft of ideas. 

On the first day, Marnus Labuschagne set the tone with a fluent century. By the second day, it was Warner’s turn to take centre stage. The Pakistani pacers, young and inexperienced, fed him a steady diet of width outside off-stump—a cardinal sin against a player of Warner’s calibre. Time and again, he punished them, turning half-chances into boundaries and opportunities into milestones. 

This wasn’t just a batting masterclass; it was a tactical dissection of an opponent. Pakistan’s captain, Azhar Ali, struggled to set attacking fields or formulate plans to stem the flow of runs. The result? A relentless onslaught from Warner, who batted for more than nine hours, smashing 39 fours and a solitary six in a display that was as composed as it was commanding. 

Joining the Elite 

Warner’s unbeaten 335 placed him among an exclusive group of Australian batsmen to have scored a triple hundred in Test cricket. He joined legends like Sir Don Bradman (who achieved the feat twice), Matthew Hayden, Mark Taylor, Bob Simpson, Bob Cowper, and Michael Clarke. Globally, Warner became the 27th batsman to reach the milestone, with the most recent being India’s Karun Nair in 2016. 

His innings also set records. Warner surpassed Bradman’s 299 as the highest-ever Test score at the Adelaide Oval. Additionally, he became only the second player to score a triple century in a Day-Night Test, joining Pakistan’s Azhar Ali, who achieved the feat in 2016 against the West Indies. 

A Home Track Bully? 

While Warner’s exploits at home are undeniably remarkable, his performances away from Australia tell a different story. In 41 Test matches and 80 innings on foreign soil, Warner averages a modest 34.50 compared to an imposing 63.78 at home. He has scored just six centuries abroad, compared to 17 in Australia—a stark disparity that raises questions about his adaptability to challenging conditions. 

Warner’s struggles were most evident during the 2019 Ashes series in England, where Stuart Broad exposed his vulnerability outside off-stump. Across five Tests, Warner managed a paltry 95 runs at an average of 9.51. Broad, in particular, exploited Warner’s weaknesses with surgical precision, consistently beating his defence and forcing errors. 

In an era of advanced analytics and video analysis, Warner’s limitations have become a blueprint for opposition bowlers. Teams like England, India, and New Zealand have effectively exploited his weaknesses, while others, like Pakistan, have yet to learn these lessons. 

The Adelaide Redemption 

Despite his overseas struggles, Warner’s ability to bounce back on home soil remains unparalleled. The Adelaide Oval proved to be the perfect stage for his redemption. As the runs flowed and records tumbled, fans—particularly those from the subcontinent—clamoured for Warner to chase Brian Lara’s iconic 400*. However, Australia’s cricketing culture has always prioritized the team over individual milestones. 

With rain looming in the forecast, Australian captain Tim Paine made the bold decision to declare the innings at 589/3, leaving Warner unbeaten on 335. The decision was pragmatic and professional, aimed at giving Australia ample time to dismantle Pakistan’s fragile batting lineup. It worked. By stumps, Pakistan was in disarray, their defeat all but inevitable. 

While fans in some parts of the world might view this decision as a missed opportunity for Warner, it underscored the Australian ethos: winning the match matters more than personal glory. 

 A Legacy Rewritten 

David Warner’s triple century at Adelaide was more than just a career milestone; it was a statement of resilience, adaptability, and evolution. For a player who once doubted his own patience, Warner demonstrated that he could combine his natural aggression with the composure required for greatness. 

However, the innings also highlighted the duality of Warner’s career—a dominant force at home but a work in progress abroad. As he continues to rewrite his legacy, Warner’s challenge will be to translate this form into success on foreign soil. 

For now, though, Warner’s 335 stands as a testament to his brilliance, a reminder of what happens when raw talent is tempered with discipline. It is a performance that will be remembered not just for the runs scored but for the transformation it symbolises. David Warner, the raging bull of Australian cricket, has shown that even the most explosive players can master the art of patience.

Thank You

Faisal Caesar  

The Renaissance of the Number 9: Robert Lewandowski’s Era of Excellence

The departure of Ronaldo Nazário, affectionately known as "O Fenômeno," marked the end of an era defined by the artistry and dynamism of the classic number 9. For years, football seemed to have moved on from the flair and flexibility of strikers like Ronaldo and Andriy Shevchenko. Instead, the game embraced pressing systems, possession-based play, and tactical innovations like the false 9, which sidelined the traditional striker in favour of more versatile, goal-scoring wingers. 

The rise of Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi redefined goal-scoring, pushing the boundaries of what was achievable from wide positions. These extraordinary talents overshadowed the need for a genuine centre-forward, leading many to believe that the days of the classic number 9 were over. However, in recent years, a new wave of strikers has emerged, reviving the role with a modern twist. 

Among them, Robert Lewandowski stands as the most complete and prolific embodiment of the number 9—a player who not only redefines the position but elevates it to new heights. 

The False 9 Era: A Tactical Necessity 

The dominance of the false 9 system in the past decade was not without precedent. It harkened back to the tactical genius of the Magnificent Magyars, who deployed Nándor Hidegkuti as a deep-lying forward to dismantle England at Wembley in 1953. Similarly, Brazil’s Tostão operated as a false 9 during their triumphant 1970 World Cup campaign, creating space for the likes of Pelé and Jairzinho. 

In the modern era, the false 9 re-emerged as a necessity when players like Messi and Ronaldo began dominating goal-scoring charts. Their ability to cut inside from wide positions and score with unerring consistency rendered the traditional striker redundant in many systems. Managers adapted, deploying midfielders or wingers in central roles to maximize the output of their star players. 

Yet, as football evolves, so does the need for balance. The resurgence of the genuine number 9 has brought a renewed appreciation for the role of a clinical, versatile striker. 

The Resurgence of the Number 9 

In this new age, strikers like Karim Benzema, Jamie Vardy, Ciro Immobile, and Robert Lewandowski have redefined what it means to be a number 9. These players are not merely poachers; they combine technical ability, positional intelligence, and adaptability to thrive in systems that demand more than just goal-scoring. 

Among them, Lewandowski has emerged as the paragon of excellence. The Polish striker’s performances for Bayern Munich and the national team have solidified his status as the best number 9 in the world today. 

Lewandowski: A Striker for the Ages  

At 31, Robert Lewandowski is enjoying the finest form of his career. His exploits in front of goal have reached historic levels, showcasing a blend of clinical finishing, technical brilliance, and tactical awareness. 

One of the most memorable displays of his prowess came in a Champions League group-stage match against Red Star Belgrade. In just 14 minutes and 31 seconds, Lewandowski scored four goals, a feat that left spectators and pundits alike in awe. This wasn’t an isolated incident; Lewandowski’s career is punctuated by moments of brilliance, including his legendary five goals in nine minutes against Wolfsburg in 2015 and a four-goal masterclass against Real Madrid in the Champions League. 

A Statistical Marvel 

Lewandowski’s numbers are staggering. In 2024, he scored 51 goals in 53 appearances for club and country, including 10 goals in just seven Champions League matches. His goals-per-minute ratio—averaging a goal every 57 minutes—outshines even the best seasons of Messi and Ronaldo. Messi’s historic 2012-13 La Liga campaign saw him score every 66 minutes, while Ronaldo’s best in 2013-14 came at 73.6 minutes per goal. Lewandowski has surpassed these benchmarks with months still left in the season. 

Evolution of a Striker 

What sets Lewandowski apart is his ability to adapt and evolve. As he ages, he has shifted from relying on intricate movements and close-range finishes to mastering long-range strikes and set-piece headers, reminiscent of Ronaldo’s transformation in his 30s. His ambidexterity and aerial prowess make him a nightmare for defenders, as Gerard Piqué aptly noted: “He can use both feet and he’s good in the air. It’s really tough when you have to mark a player that can do everything.” 

Lewandowski is not just a finisher; he is an all-round performer. He combines the cool composure of Jamie Vardy, the technical finesse of Karim Benzema, and the positional intelligence of Ciro Immobile. His ability to score in a variety of ways—whether through volleys, headers, or long-range strikes—makes him a unique asset in modern football. 

The Best Number 9 

In an era where the role of the striker has been redefined, Robert Lewandowski stands as a beacon of the classic number 9, infused with modern versatility. His consistency, adaptability, and relentless pursuit of goals have cemented his place as the best striker in the world today. 

As the season progresses, Lewandowski’s current form suggests that greater feats are yet to come. If his trajectory continues, he may well be remembered not just as the best of his generation, but as one of the greatest number 9s in the history of football. 

The renaissance of the number 9 is here, and Robert Lewandowski is leading the charge.

Thank You

Faisal Caesar 

Neymar’s Subtle Symphony: A Masterclass in Deep-Playmaking

Real Madrid stormed onto the pitch against Paris Saint-Germain (PSG) with a vigour befitting their storied legacy. Their tactical setup, a midfield diamond anchored by the indomitable Casemiro and the industrious Fede Valverde, exuded control and precision. Isco, operating as the creative fulcrum, added a touch of artistry to the structure, granting freedom to the attackers and effectively stifling PSG’s rhythm for much of the game. 

For PSG, the midfield had been a cornerstone of their success under Thomas Tuchel, with Marquinhos and Idrissa Gueye forming a resilient partnership. However, Real Madrid’s tactical discipline dismantled this dynamic duo. Isco’s relentless man-marking of Marquinhos and the dual pressure from Casemiro and Valverde on Gueye disrupted PSG’s buildup play, forcing Tuchel to rethink his approach. 

The turning point came in the second half when Tuchel introduced Neymar, a decision born of necessity rather than strategy. Gueye was sacrificed to make way for the Brazilian maestro, who was returning from injury and visibly short of match fitness. 

The Evolution of Neymar’s Game 

Neymar’s initial touches were tentative, a reflection of his lack of sharpness. Yet, as the minutes ticked by, he began to weave his magic, not through blistering pace or direct dribbles, but through subtler, more cerebral means. His movements bore the hallmark of a player transitioning from explosive brilliance to calculated artistry. 

Drawing comparisons to Diego Maradona’s performances during Italia ’90, Neymar relied on deft touches, body feints, and short, incisive passes to influence the game from deeper positions. These "depth touches," as they can be aptly described, allowed him to dictate the tempo, creating opportunities not by overpowering defenders but by outthinking them. 

The Catalyst for PSG’s Revival 

Neymar’s impact was most evident in PSG’s equalizer. Breaking free from Real Madrid’s defensive shackles, he orchestrated a sequence that epitomized his unique skill set. With a subtle shift of his body, he evaded his marker and advanced into the midfield, linking up with a teammate in a quick one-two before threading a precise pass to the left flank. 

The ensuing low cross caused chaos in Real Madrid’s defence, ultimately leading to Pablo Sarabia pouncing on a deflection to score. While the finish was opportunistic, the genesis of the goal lay in Neymar’s vision and composure. Moments later, Kylian Mbappé capitalized on another defensive lapse to score, exposing vulnerabilities in Real Madrid’s backline. 

A Forward Who Thinks Like a Playmaker 

What sets Neymar apart from his contemporaries is his ability to transcend the traditional role of a forward. In an era where most attackers rely on pace and power, Neymar operates as a hybrid—a forward with the mind of a playmaker. His deep positioning and ability to dictate play from behind are rare qualities, reminiscent of football’s greatest tacticians. 

Despite his limited involvement due to fitness concerns, Neymar’s performance against Real Madrid was a testament to why he remains one of the most sought-after players in the world. Big clubs covet his unique blend of flair and intelligence, recognizing that even in moments of physical limitation, his ability to influence the game remains unparalleled. 

Real Madrid’s Defensive Fragility 

While Neymar’s brilliance deserves recognition, it also highlighted glaring issues in Real Madrid’s defence. The lack of urgency in closing down crosses and the ease with which PSG’s forwards found space exposed a vulnerability that cannot be ignored. 

However, to focus solely on defensive lapses would be to undermine the artistry of Neymar’s contribution. His ability to turn a half-chance into a goal-scoring opportunity underscores his genius—a quality that elevates him into the realm of football’s legends. 

The Maestro Returns 

Neymar’s performance was a reminder of his enduring brilliance, even in the face of adversity. He may not have been at his physical peak, but his mind was as sharp as ever, orchestrating PSG’s comeback with the finesse of a maestro conducting a symphony. 

In a game defined by tactical battles and individual brilliance, Neymar once again proved why he is a player for the ages—a footballer who, even when not fully fit, can bend the narrative to his will. 

Thank You

Faisal Caesar