Saturday, March 29, 2025

A House Divided: Brazil’s Coaching Crisis and the Quiet Fall of Dorival Júnior

Long before Brazil kicked a ball in the March international window, a quiet revolution had already begun behind the scenes. Conversations had taken place, discreet yet decisive, and the writing was already on the wall for head coach Dorival Júnior. The Brazilian Football Confederation (CBF), under the leadership of Ednaldo Rodrigues, had communicated its enduring desire to bring Carlo Ancelotti into the fold—a courtship that had lingered across continents and calendars. In the same breath, the name Jorge Jesus began to reappear in internal discussions, not as an ideal dream but as a more tangible, present possibility.

These early movements were not simply reactions to performance; they were part of a broader recalibration at the top of Brazilian football. The upcoming presidential election of the CBF, scheduled on the eve of Brazil's showdown against Argentina, created a perfect moment for power consolidation. Rodrigues, a seasoned operator, recognized the opportunity to reassert control. As tensions simmered within the federation, he removed himself from the daily operations of a FIFA international break long marked as a judgment week for Dorival and his staff.

Silence in Brasília: The Sound of Discontent

The Seleção’s base in Brasília during the March fixtures became a crucible of pressure and unspoken uncertainty. The absence of the CBF president during critical preparation phases was interpreted not as neglect, but as a deliberate distancing. In football, absence often speaks louder than words. It was a clear signal that only truly exceptional performances could reverse a decision already in motion.

Internally, Dorival and his coaching staff had set a realistic target: four points from two games. It was a modest ambition meant to ease the tension—particularly if a draw could be earned in the fierce atmosphere of Buenos Aires. But the scars of a disappointing performance against Colombia had not yet healed. Brazil’s fragile momentum made every game feel like a referendum.

Rodrigues finally arrived in Brasília on the day of the 4-1 win over Colombia, and he stayed through the next day's defeat to Argentina. In public, Dorival maintained dignity. He praised the support structures in place and insisted the president had provided the tools necessary to succeed. But in the locker room, the energy had already shifted. It was not the scene of a triumphant revival—it was the quiet recognition of a relationship running its course. No embraces, no rallying words, no promise of tomorrow.

The Art of Surgical Dismissal

Perhaps the most intriguing part of this story is not that Dorival was dismissed—but how. Rodrigues’s strategy wasn’t a sweeping purge but a precise operation. The president separated the coaching staff from the rest of the national team department, an unorthodox move that sent ripples through the corridors of power.

Director Rodrigo Caetano, expected by many to be a central figure in any such decisions, was not consulted. He had no part in the initial overtures to Ancelotti nor in the more recent dialogues surrounding Jorge Jesus. This exclusion speaks volumes about the nature of power within the CBF—centralized, opaque, and firmly held by Rodrigues.

Still, there were hints that the president’s intentions weren’t wholesale dismissal. Just before the meeting that would officially end Dorival’s tenure, team manager Cícero Souza was confirmed to be travelling to Colombia. There, he was to assist Branco in overseeing the U-17 national team’s campaign in the South American Championship, which had opened with a 1-1 draw against Uruguay. Why send someone abroad on federation duty if he was to be relieved the next day? It was a subtle sign of selective pruning rather than a full reset.

In the end, only those tied directly to Dorival were asked to step aside. Assistants Lucas Silvestre and Pedro Sotero, physical trainer Celso Rezende, and team supervisor Sérgio Dimas—all closely linked to the coach’s career—were let go. Curiously, technical coordinator Juan, a recommendation by Dorival, remained. It was a rare thread of continuity in an otherwise disjointed transition.

The Road Ahead: June and the Shadow of Jesus

Dorival’s departure creates not just a vacancy but a vacuum—one the CBF must fill quickly. With the next FIFA window in June looming, Brazil must appoint a new head coach soon to keep its 2026 World Cup campaign on track and reorient a program in disarray.

Jorge Jesus, currently at Saudi club Al Hilal, remains the likeliest candidate. His willingness to forgo participation in the Club World Cup signals both his availability and interest. However, he has expressed a desire to guide Al Hilal through the final stages of the Asian Champions League, a campaign that concludes in early May. Should Brazil want him—and all signs point to that being the case—the timing could align.

What remains clear is that this new chapter in Brazilian football will not be written solely on the field. It is being forged in the boardrooms, in whispered conversations, in emails and unofficial overtures. The pursuit of a sixth World Cup title, Brazil’s holy grail, is now as much about institutional vision and executive manoeuvring as it is about talent and tactics.

Conclusion: The Mirror of a Nation

Brazil’s national team has always been more than a collection of players. It is a mirror of the nation’s aspirations, anxieties, and contradictions. The fall of Dorival Júnior—quiet, calculated, and cold—reflects a federation striving for control and clarity amid a chaotic global football landscape.

As the Seleção looks to rebuild, what emerges is a portrait of transition: not just of coaching philosophies, but of leadership, power dynamics, and identity. Whether the next man in charge is Ancelotti, Jorge Jesus, or another name yet to be whispered in Rio’s corridors, the challenge remains the same: to heal the fractures, inspire a generation, and once again make Brazil the beating heart of world football.

Thank You

Faisal Caesar 

No comments:

Post a Comment