Monday, November 16, 2026

Babar Azam and the Unfinished Argument for Greatness

There comes a point in a celebrated batsman’s career when elegance ceases to be an argument. The cover drive has been admired, the technique examined, the comparisons made. What remains is a harder question: how often has he imposed himself on a match strongly enough to change its course?

For Babar Azam, that question remains inconveniently open.

His Test batting average this year offers a persuasive defence. Across 12 innings, he has scored 489 runs at 48.90, with five half-centuries. Among batsmen who have played at least ten innings, he leads the averages. These are respectable figures, particularly after averaging 20.20 in 2024 and 31.50 in 2025. They suggest recovery, and recovery deserves recognition.

But recovery and greatness demand different evidence.

Babar’s year has produced several beginnings and very little completion. He has occupied the crease, resisted difficult bowling and occasionally rescued an innings from immediate collapse. What he has seldom done is remain long enough to turn that resistance into authority. His batting has repeatedly brought Pakistan to the threshold of possibility, then left someone else to open the door.

The Distance between Contribution and Command

Against Bangladesh in Sylhet, his scores of 68 and 47 amounted to a substantial contribution. Yet both innings ended when something larger appeared possible. Pakistan lost by 78 runs.

It would be simplistic to place that defeat at Babar’s feet. Eleven men constitute a cricket team, and a batsman cannot repair every weakness around him. Still, the expectations surrounding an elite player necessarily exceed those applied to a useful contributor. A fifty may steady an innings. A prolonged innings can alter the conditions under which everyone else plays.

That distinction matters when greatness is being claimed.

In the West Indies, Babar’s unbeaten 58 in a failed pursuit of 211 was an honourable act of resistance. Pakistan were dismissed for 120; Mohammad Abbas, with 23, was the only other batsman to reach double figures. Here, criticism requires restraint. Abandonment by the rest of the batting order cannot reasonably become evidence of Babar’s inadequacy.

The questions about his handling of the tail are legitimate, although strike management rarely offers the certainty that hindsight pretends it does. That innings deserves credit. It also illustrates how frequently the argument for Babar now rests on his having suffered less visibly than those around him.

At Port of Spain, an even clearer opportunity disappeared. He reached 88 before a misunderstanding with Abdullah Shafique ended in a run-out. His series return—193 runs at 96.50—was excellent. Yet the dismissal prolonged a familiar frustration: another innings promising a definitive statement, another statement left unfinished.

What The Average cannot Settle

A batting average records outcomes with admirable precision. It cannot, by itself, explain the weight of those outcomes.

Babar’s four unbeaten innings this year mean that his 489 runs are divided by ten dismissals. There is nothing illegitimate about that calculation; remaining unbeaten is often an achievement. But it helps explain how a batsman can lead the averages without producing the commanding innings supporters associate with that position.

The figure establishes consistency more convincingly than dominance.

England exposed another part of the problem. Returning after injury, Babar made 8, 6 and 7 in his first three innings. Jofra Archer’s swing and Josh Tongue’s bounce challenged him. These were precisely the conditions in which an acclaimed batsman’s reputation required substance.

His subsequent 76 at Birmingham was valuable. With Pakistan having made 133 in their first innings and then slipped to nought for two in the second, he helped begin a considerable recovery. Pakistan eventually reached 449.

That innings belongs in any fair assessment of his year. But it also sharpens the central criticism. Having survived the most dangerous passage and established himself, could he have carried the innings further? Great batting careers acquire their stature through the repeated conversion of such opportunities.

The Burden of an Unfinished Reputation

Against Sri Lanka, 50 and 34 supplied further evidence of competence. They offered less evidence of distinction in a match where other Pakistani batsmen also found runs.

Babar’s latest Test century remains the one he scored in December 2022. A century is an arbitrary boundary: 99 can be more valuable than 100, and a difficult 70 can outweigh an indulgent 150. Nevertheless, a prolonged absence of hundreds eventually becomes significant. It raises questions about concentration, conversion and the ability to sustain control after the initial contest has been negotiated.

The wider context offers mitigation. Harry Brook, second on this year’s averages among the same qualifying group, has also gone without a century. Established batsmen have found this a demanding year. Babar’s position therefore deserves respect.

It does not settle his standing among the greats.

Nor should Pakistan’s failures become the sole measure of his worth. Great batsmen can inhabit weak teams. Their distinction often lies in how much uncertainty they remove from those teams: how frequently a promising start becomes a substantial innings, how reliably survival develops into command.

Babar has demonstrated the skill to belong at the highest level. The outstanding question concerns the scale and frequency of his influence there.

For now, his reputation continues to draw heavily on what his batting appears capable of becoming. Greatness requires a fuller record of what it has actually accomplished. Until those elegant beginnings more regularly become innings of lasting consequence, the argument will remain unfinished.

Thank You 

Faisal Caesar 

No comments:

Post a Comment