Pakistan's Test Woes: A Familiar Collapse in South Africa

The questions surrounding Pakistan's batting are perennial, almost a ritualistic discourse in cricketing circles: *When will the lineup collapse? How long before the opposition seals the match?*

In the second Test against South Africa, these questions were answered with ruthless efficiency. With two days still in hand and 228 runs needed to script a comeback, Pakistan folded predictably, showcasing yet again their perennial fragility in alien conditions. The visitors succumbed to a whitewash—a result as inevitable as it was disheartening.

A Tale of Two Missing Pillars 

The absence of Younis Khan and Misbah-ul-Haq has left an irreplaceable void in Pakistan’s Test lineup. Post their retirement, the baton was expected to pass to Asad Shafiq and Azhar Ali—batters groomed in the shadows of these stalwarts. Yet, their inability to shoulder responsibility has left Pakistan's batting brittle, especially overseas.

Azhar Ali’s numbers, while respectable at first glance, unravel under scrutiny. His career average of 43.27 dips to 37.41 away from home. In the SENA (South Africa, England, New Zealand, and Australia) countries, the disparity becomes stark. Apart from a solitary bright spot in Australia, where he averages a remarkable 81.20, his numbers plummet: a dismal 16.00 in South Africa, 29.68 in England, and 29.42 in New Zealand. 

Shafiq, touted as a middle-order mainstay, has fared no better. His career average of 38.94 flatters to deceive, buoyed largely by runs on placid tracks in the UAE. In testing conditions, the cracks widen: averages of 36.5 in England, 32.08 in South Africa, and 23.28 in New Zealand. For two players with over 60 Tests under their belts, such mediocrity is damning.

The Missing Fight 

Batting in SENA countries requires more than just technique; it demands grit, adaptability, and the will to fight against the odds. This is where Pakistan’s senior batters have faltered most glaringly. Instead of shielding younger players like Babar Azam, Imam-ul-Haq, or Shan Masood from fiery pace attacks, they’ve exposed them to the lions' den unprepared. 

Babar’s audacious stroke play against Dale Steyn and Masood’s unexpected resolve offered glimpses of potential, but these were mere flickers in a sea of darkness. Captain Sarfraz Ahmed, while not expected to anchor innings as a specialist batter, has failed to inspire his team as a leader. The captaincy in Test cricket demands a vision and a steeliness that Sarfraz has yet to demonstrate.

A Perennial Problem 

This series was not a new chapter but a rerun of an all-too-familiar script. Since the departure of Pakistan’s batting greats of the 1990s and 2000s, tours of South Africa have become an exercise in futility. The team often goes through the motions, returning home with fleeting positives and lessons unlearned. 

The blame lies not only with individuals but also with a collective mindset. Without meticulous planning, mental preparation, and a genuine hunger for success abroad, Pakistan’s Test progress will remain stagnant. The need for accountability, strategy, and leadership cannot be overstated. 

A Call for Change 

If Pakistan aspires to be competitive in Test cricket, especially overseas, the status quo must be challenged. The transition from flat-track dominance to consistent performances in hostile conditions will demand a cultural shift. Batters like Azhar and Shafiq must either rediscover their fighting spirit or make way for a new generation willing to embrace the challenge.

For now, the haunting echoes of another South African whitewash remain—a bitter reminder of what Pakistan cricket could be, but isn’t.

Thank You

Faisal Caesar

Ireland’s Historic Test: Pakistan Survive the Malahide Scare

Under the brooding grey skies of Malahide, Pakistan emerged to chase 160 runs on the final day of Ireland’s inaugural Test match. It was a target that, on paper, seemed modest, but for Pakistan—a team notorious for faltering in fourth-innings chases—the spectre of past collapses loomed large. The ghosts of Galle, Sydney, and Abu Dhabi haunted the minds of fans, and early on, it seemed Malahide might join that list. 

Tim Murtagh and Boyd Rankin, with their probing lines and relentless discipline, dismantled Pakistan’s top order in the opening overs. At 14 for 3, the visitors were teetering on the brink of calamity. Irish fans, their flags fluttering proudly, roared in anticipation of a monumental upset. Victory would have made Ireland only the second team to win their debut Test and the fourth to triumph after following on. 

But Pakistan’s young guns, Imam-ul-Haq and Babar Azam, had other plans. With remarkable composure, they steadied the ship, playing late and under their eyes to counter the moving ball. Their partnership, built on grit and patience, turned the tide. Though two more wickets fell before the chase was completed, the pair had done enough to ensure Pakistan escaped a historic Irish ambush. 

A Batting Line-Up in Flux

While Pakistan’s bowlers once again delivered, their batting remains a persistent Achilles’ heel. The absence of stalwarts like Younis Khan and Misbah-ul-Haq continues to haunt the middle order. Azhar Ali and Asad Shafiq, the designated torchbearers of this batting line-up, have yet to fill the void consistently. 

Azhar Ali, undoubtedly one of Pakistan’s most dependable batsmen in recent years, struggles on seaming tracks. His tendency to play with a heavy front foot and his vulnerability to deliveries angling into the middle and leg stump often render him ineffective in conditions favouring swing and seam. His struggles in England and New Zealand are a testament to this flaw, and unless he adapts by playing the ball later and with softer hands, his contributions will remain sporadic. 

Asad Shafiq, meanwhile, is an enigma. Technically sound and capable of producing breathtaking innings, his career has been marred by inconsistency. While he has played some of Pakistan’s finest Test knocks, his inability to build on starts and his penchant for losing concentration at crucial junctures have been frustrating. His form oscillates between brilliance and mediocrity, disrupting the team’s rhythm. 

Sarfraz’s Role and the Young Brigade

Captain Sarfraz Ahmed’s role at number six is pivotal. Known for his resilience under pressure, Sarfraz has the temperament and technique to stabilize innings when chaos reigns. However, as both captain and wicketkeeper, he shoulders immense responsibility. For Pakistan to thrive in England, Sarfraz must lead by example, curbing rash strokes and anchoring the lower middle order. 

The team’s younger players, though talented, lack the experience and technical finesse to thrive in challenging conditions. Fakhar Zaman’s explosive starts, while valuable, must be tempered with an understanding of the Test match tempo. Usman Salahuddin’s measured half-century against Leicestershire in a warm-up game was a promising sign, but the real test lies in withstanding the relentless examination of Anderson, Broad, and company. 

Lessons from 2016 and the Road Ahead

Pakistan’s 2016 tour of England offers a blueprint for success. Then, the experience of Younis and Misbah, coupled with Yasir Shah’s spin, propelled them to memorable performances. Today, the absence of such seasoned campaigners makes the task exponentially harder. To succeed, Pakistan’s batsmen must embrace the fundamentals: trust their defence, play the ball late, and occupy the crease. The allure of adventurous strokes must be resisted, for survival in England demands discipline above all else. 

The warm-up game against Leicestershire, while offering little in terms of quality opposition, provided crucial confidence. Fakhar and Azhar’s century opening stand and Salahuddin’s patient knock were heartening signs. Yet, the real battle begins against England—a team transformed into a juggernaut in home conditions, with pacers who exploit every nuance of the Duke ball. 

The Verdict

Malahide was a wake-up call. It exposed Pakistan’s vulnerabilities but also showcased their ability to claw back from the brink. To succeed in England, they must channel that same resilience, leaning on their bowlers while demanding more from their batsmen. The ghosts of collapses past still linger, but with the right application, this Pakistan side has the potential to rewrite its narrative. 

In cricket, as in life, it is often not the most talented who prevail but the most adaptable. For Pakistan, the challenge is clear: adapt, endure, and thrive in the face of adversity. Only then can they hope to turn the promise of Malahide into a sustained resurgence on the world stage.

Thank You\

Faisal Caesar  

Asad Shafiq: The Unsung Warrior of Pakistan Cricket

When Asad Shafiq first stepped into the cauldron of international cricket, the spotlight was fixed elsewhere—on Umar Akmal, a prodigious talent touted as Pakistan’s next big thing. Umar had ignited imaginations with his debut year but quickly became an enigma, a riddle Pakistan cricket could never solve. In contrast, Shafiq quietly carved out a niche for himself, unburdened by hype yet relentless in his quest for excellence. His journey has been one of patience and perseverance, and in the shadow of fleeting brilliance, he has emerged as Pakistan's reliable stabilizer.

A Turbulent Canvas for Greatness

The setting was Brisbane, 2016—the first-ever day-night Test at the Gabba, and Pakistan’s hopes appeared to have been extinguished. After Mohammad Amir’s incandescent spell in the first innings, where he extracted venomous movement from the pink ball, Pakistan’s batting capitulated comically. From 43 for 1 to 67 for 8, the implosion was as spectacular as it was predictable. Hard hands and poor judgment saw the top order flounder against Australia’s pace battery.

A minor act of defiance from Sarfraz Ahmed and Amir helped Pakistan scrape past 100, but by then, Australia had piled on a daunting lead. The fourth innings target of 490 seemed insurmountable—a task fit only for miracles.

And then, from the wreckage of collapse, Asad Shafiq emerged.

A Spark of Resistance

When Shafiq strode to the crease, Pakistan teetered at 220 for 6, their stalwarts—Azhar Ali, Younis Khan, and Misbah-ul-Haq—back in the pavilion. The end seemed imminent. Yet, Shafiq, a man enduring a wretched patch of form since the England tour, found within himself the resolve to rewrite the narrative.

He forged a rearguard of remarkable grit, first with Amir and later with Wahab Riaz, dragging Pakistan back into the contest. With deft placement and precise timing, Shafiq accumulated runs, surviving early jitters and capitalizing on slices of fortune—two dropped catches at 58 and 72. He played with a craftsman’s care, resurrecting his side from the ashes of despair.

His hundred was more than just a statistic; it was an assertion of character. In surpassing Sir Garfield Sobers’ record for centuries at the number six position, Shafiq inscribed his name into cricket’s storied annals. By the end of the fourth day, Pakistan had improbably reached 382 for 8, leaving the world spellbound.

Though Mitchell Starc’s venomous delivery eventually ended Shafiq’s epic vigil on the final day, his innings had already secured its place in the pantheon of great fourth-innings knocks. Pakistan may have lost the match, but Shafiq had won hearts worldwide.

A Karachi-Bred Grit

Hailing from Karachi—a city that embodies chaos and resilience—Shafiq represents a lineage of tough, uncompromising cricketers. The names that echo through Karachi’s cricketing history—Hanif Mohammad, Mushtaq Mohammad, Javed Miandad, and Mohammad Yousuf—have shaped the narrative of Pakistan cricket with grit, guile, and audacity.

Yet, Shafiq is an outlier in this tradition. Unlike Miandad’s swagger or Yousuf’s poetic artistry, he approaches the game with quiet determination. There is no theatricality in his batsmanship, no flamboyance that demands attention. Instead, Shafiq embodies the understated virtues of discipline and patience.

Technically sound and temperamentally unflappable, he brings a modern-day Steve Waugh-esque approach to the crease. Like Waugh, Shafiq is a late bloomer, earning respect not through prodigious talent but through hard-fought performances.

The Anchor at Number Six

Shafiq’s role in the batting order is pivotal. As a number six, he is the stabilizer—a firefighter who douses collapses and builds critical partnerships. His ability to play late and with soft hands makes him particularly adept against high-quality fast bowling, as evidenced by his performances at Newlands, Lord’s, and now Brisbane. He prioritizes strike rotation over boundary-hitting, crafting innings with subtlety rather than spectacle.

In a batting lineup often marred by inconsistency, Shafiq’s methodical approach offers a calming presence. While modern audiences may pine for adventurous stroke play, his quiet accumulation of runs is precisely what Pakistan’s volatile batting lineup requires.

Room for Growth: Consistency as the Next Frontier

Despite his undeniable talent and invaluable contributions, Shafiq has yet to achieve the consistency required to cement his place among the greats. His form often vacillates between brilliance and mediocrity—a trait he must overcome if he is to shoulder the responsibility of Pakistan's middle order in the post-Misbah-Younis era.

But Shafiq has the tools to succeed. His resilience, technical soundness, and hunger for improvement position him as a vital cog in Pakistan’s Test setup. With Misbah and Younis nearing retirement, Shafiq’s calm leadership and dependable batting will be indispensable in navigating the team through a period of transition.

A Symbol of Grit

Asad Shafiq may lack the prodigious flair of a Tendulkar or the sheer dominance of a Viv Richards, but he is a cricketer of substance—a craftsman who builds innings brick by brick. In an era where cricket often glorifies the audacious, Shafiq is a quiet reminder of the enduring value of perseverance, hard work, and humility.

At Brisbane, he didn’t just save face for Pakistan; he demonstrated the indomitable spirit that lies at the heart of their cricketing culture. If he continues to evolve and refine his game, Shafiq could well become the stabilizing force Pakistan cricket so desperately needs. For now, he stands as a testament to the power of resilience—a warrior who fights not for glory but for his team’s cause.

Thank You

Faisal Caesar  

Pakistan’s special turnaround at The Oval

If the defeat at Manchester was vexatious, then the defeat at Edgbaston was hard to digest as at one point, Pakistan were in a very commanding position. But the Pakistanis, let the match slip out of their hands, and thus, before the start of the fourth Test match at The Oval, the mood in the Pakistan camp was downcast. The Pakistan batting line-up had been irreconcilable at Manchester and Edgbaston, while the sloppy fielding and Yasir Shah’s struggle added extra worries for the Pakistani think-tank. Obviously, Pakistan were not expected to stun England and level the series.

Wahab Riaz’s fiery pace jolted the English batting line-up and when Garry Ballance was dismissed, England were reeling at 110 for 5.

But Moeen Ali and Jonny Bairstow took the game away from Pakistan on day 1. Both of them were the beneficiaries of key reprieves early in their innings, which left Pakistan to rue and another partnership between Moeen and Chris Woakes floored Pakistan and, it seemed, they won’t be able to make a comeback after the Moeen-Bairstow-Woakes show.

At stumps, Pakistan were 3 for 1 and the critics were expecting yet another inauspicious display from the Pakistani batsmen on a track that was offering plenty of assistance for the pace bowlers. But the first hour of the second day changed the complexion of the match and put Pakistan in a commendable position.

Yasir Shah’s brilliant resistance in the first hour of day 2 set the tempo for Pakistan

Against the top teams of the world, the first session of a Test match, especially, the first hour of play, always matters. The Pakistan think-tank sent Yasir Shah as the nightwatchman and the kind of form the Pakistani tailenders had been throughout the series, Yasir was supposed to be an easy wicket. Now, an early loss of a wicket in the first hour of play automatically puts enormous pressure on the batting line-up which is struggling to get out of the lean patch. But the decision to send Yasir as the nightwatchman proved to be a masterstroke.

For one hour, Yasir weather storm of Stuart Broad and James Anderson efficiently and scored a valuable 26 runs, which not only started the day for Pakistan brightly but gave them the momentum which was much needed.

Asad Shafiq’s promotion up the order reaped a rich harvest

At the other end, Azhar Ali kept on going and never let the momentum shift in favor of England and stitched a 75-run stand with Asad Shafiq who was batting at number 4 instead of 6. Shafiq had been another customer who was found wanting in the previous two Test matches and the decision to send him at number four was not a gamble, but a well-thought one as this position suits his style very much and struck a wonderful hundred to strengthen Pakistan’s authority over the Test match.

Never dare to write off veteran Younis Khan

Shafiq’s departure left a huge responsibility on Younis Khan to carry on the momentum and bat England out of the game. In the previous three Test matches, Younis Khan’s dance at the crease and poor shot selection had been criticized, but at The Oval, he was in a different zone. He played the ball late, went behind the ball, and used his feet masterfully to essay yet another comeback innings. Younis Khan scripted a brilliant 218 which bolstered Pakistan’s innings big time and shut the mouth of those critics who had written off Younis a million times.

Mohammad Amir’s resistance with the bat

Throughout the Test match, the Pakistani tail was reluctant to fight and this hurt Pakistan badly at Edgbaston. But at The Oval, the Pakistani tailenders decided to change the mood and dished out a stubborn resistance which surely had made Hanif Mohammad proud in heaven.

After Yasir Shah, Mohammad Amir showed his capabilities with the bat. He defended so well and his calm presence at the crease provided the perfect foil to Younis’ composure who could not have scored his double ton had he not received support from Amir. Both Amir and Younis stitched a partnership of 117 runs for the ninth wicket and the game was almost over for England.

Set an attacking field to encourage the bowlers

Misbah-ul-Haq’s field setting had been the subject of criticism in the previous three Test matches, but he got things right as soon as England’s second innings started. Misbah maneuvered the field very well and hardly was in a defensive mode. In the last session of day 3, he engaged three slips, a leg slip, a catching man at short mid-off and short leg for Amir, and crowed the fielders around the bat while Yasir was bowling.

Such a fieldset, motivated the bowlers to bowl with aggressive intent, and immediately England were four down at the stumps on day 3.

Yasir Shah loves to bowl in London

Misbah’s attacking mindset didn’t change on day 4 and he kept on attacking with his premium bowler Yasir Shah. Yasir changed his game-plan a bit – he varied his pace a lot and the quicker ones hit the deck without turning and hit the batsmen’s pad like a missile. His line of attack varied in between middle-and-off and middle stump and utilized the footmarks intelligently like Shane Warne to sink England.

Unpredictable Pakistan

It’s never easy to bounce back after digesting back-to-back humiliating defeats, but when the team is Pakistan; either you can expect them to script another comical show or an exhibition like the cornered Tigers.

The Pakistan team at The Oval were the cornered Tigers. It was a magnificent win and the perfect tribute to the late Hanif Mohammad.

Misbah-ul-Haq and his men worked very hard to gift his nation such a special turnaround on Independence Day.

Note: This article has been published at Cricketsoccer on 14/08/2016 Pakistan’s special turnaround at The Oval 

Thank You

Faisal Caesar 

Echoes of Despair and Determination: Pakistan's Champions Trophy Heartbreak

The Oval witnessed a match that will be remembered for its nerve-wracking suspense. Cricket lovers around the world were drawn into the drama of a low-scoring thriller as Pakistan and the West Indies clashed in a contest that tested patience, passion, and skill. Pakistan’s fragile batting lineup was held up by the strength of their bowlers, who crafted a display of skill and grit that almost pulled off the impossible. Yet, in the final moments, the West Indies clinched the win, maintaining their unbeaten record against Pakistan at this historic venue. 

Days later in Cardiff, Sri Lanka delivered another spellbinding low-scorer against New Zealand, a game where fate seemed to tease, almost mocking Sri Lanka's valiant efforts. Chasing a modest target of 138, Sri Lanka's bowlers turned the tables on the Kiwis, transforming what appeared a simple chase into a labyrinthine ordeal. But just as the finish line came into sight, the Kiwis edged across to claim victory. The scoreboard may have favoured New Zealand, but it was Sri Lanka’s fighting spirit that left a lasting impression on fans.

These games were reminders of cricket's essence—that often, the thrill is greatest when batters struggle against bowlers. When the balance tilts towards the ball, the game sheds its one-dimensionality and transforms into an intricate battle of resilience and wits. Yet, amidst these memorable matches, it was not just the contests themselves that captured attention; it was the unwavering spirit of Pakistan’s fans. At the Oval, as Wahab Riaz’s pace electrified the crowd and Misbah-ul-Haq’s solitary fight drew cheers, the supporters erupted in roars that could have easily belonged to Karachi or Lahore. These fans, their hearts brimming with dreams, projected faith in their team, a fervor undeterred by setbacks on or off the field.

In their second match against South Africa at Edgbaston, Pakistan’s fans once again brought the thunderous spirit of home to a foreign land. The chants of "Pakistan jite ga" and "Pakistan Zindabad" turned the stadium into a cauldron of emotion. Pakistan's bowlers took this energy to heart, keeping South Africa’s batting in check with a disciplined attack. Yet, as the run chase of 235 began, Pakistan’s batting crumbled once more. What should have been a straightforward task quickly devolved into frustration, with batsmen faltering against a South African bowling lineup lacking their key fast bowlers, Steyn and Morkel. Misbah’s lone resistance could not prevent what became another tame surrender.

As the crowd looked on in disbelief, the dreams of millions of Pakistanis were dashed, their hopes betrayed not by a superior opponent but by a string of self-inflicted wounds. This performance left an ache in the hearts of Pakistan’s fans, their faces reflecting the disappointment of a nation that expected its heroes to rise to the occasion.

Yet, while their losses were disheartening, it was the systemic flaws in Pakistan’s approach that cast a shadow over their campaign. Selection decisions, like the continued choice of Imran Farhat, defied logic. Despite repeated failures, Farhat was trusted yet again, while proven talents like Asad Shafiq were left on the sidelines. Shafiq, with his versatility, would have brought much-needed stability to the lineup—an attribute lacking in his replacement, Umar Amin. Equally perplexing was the inclusion of Shoaib Malik, whose contributions had dwindled in recent years. Neither with bat nor ball had Malik justified his place, yet he was chosen over more deserving players. 

Pakistan’s approach to building their team has become increasingly myopic. Rather than balancing a side with both batting and bowling strengths, the selection committee appears fixated on an endless quest for fast bowlers. While Pakistan’s pace legacy is well-earned, the team needs a balanced roster to compete at the highest levels. A solid batting lineup is not a luxury; it’s a necessity, and the lack of investment in finding or nurturing batting talent has left Pakistan’s batsmen consistently underprepared for the international stage.

The team’s management must take a hard look at its priorities. Rather than focusing solely on nurturing bowlers, Pakistan should invest in finding and fostering batting talent, implementing a batsman-hunting program to unearth and develop players who can carry the team forward. Pakistan is a land rich in cricketing potential; its players have the natural flair and instinct that can rival the best in the world. What’s missing is not talent but the vision to recognize it and the commitment to nurture it.

Finally, there’s the question of coaching. The history of Pakistani cricket tells us that some of the country’s finest moments have come under the guidance of Pakistani coaches who understand the cultural nuances, the temperament of the players, and the soul of Pakistan cricket. Foreign coaches bring valuable experience, but it’s often under a Pakistani coach that the players find the freedom to excel, motivated by a sense of shared identity and purpose.

Pakistan’s Champions Trophy campaign may have ended in disappointment, but it is a wake-up call to take bold steps for the future. True progress will come not from isolated victories or fleeting moments of brilliance but from a concerted effort to cultivate a balanced and resilient team. Only then will Pakistan be ready to deliver performances that match the boundless passion of its fans and bring pride to a nation that holds cricket close to its heart.

 

Thank You

Faisal Caesar