Cricket need not die to lose its soul. It can keep its stadiums full, its television revenues rising and its sponsors satisfied while becoming a smaller game: fewer meaningful rivalries, fewer independent centres of power, fewer opportunities for countries whose greatest misfortune is to command a modest broadcasting market.
That is the danger posed by India’s growing control of the
sport. Through the BCCI’s financial strength and the IPL’s expanding
gravitational pull, one country’s commercial priorities increasingly threaten
to become everybody else’s obligations.
India has given cricket extraordinary players, vast
audiences and immense wealth. Those contributions deserve recognition. They do
not confer ownership.
The decisions emerging from the ICC’s meetings in Bali
sharpen this concern. Jay Shah, the former BCCI secretary, has been reappointed
unopposed as ICC chair. His appointment is legitimate; its unanimity
nevertheless raises a question that the congratulatory statements cannot
answer: how effectively can cricket scrutinise concentrated power when its
governing board offers no competing candidate?
An uncontested election does not establish institutional
capture. Neither does it establish healthy independence. In a sport shaped by
profound inequalities of income and bargaining power, consensus deserves
examination.
Sometimes everybody agrees because an argument has
prevailed. Sometimes nobody can afford to disagree.
The calendar provides a more tangible reason for concern.
The ICC’s approved men’s events schedule for 2028–2035 places the white-ball
tournaments in October and November, apart from the July–August T20 World Cups
in 2030 and 2034. World Test Championship finals remain in June. None of these
events occupies March, April or May.
That schedule alone does not prove a formally protected
three-month IPL window. Its practical significance, however, is difficult to
overlook: the flagship international tournaments leave precisely the stretch of
the year in which the IPL operates unobstructed.
A calendar is a constitution written in dates. It reveals
which competitions receive certainty and which must negotiate for whatever
remains.
For the richest league, certainty means stronger commercial planning. For a smaller cricket nation, uncertainty can mean struggling to assemble its best side, attract a broadcaster or sustain a worthwhile home season. The imbalance deepens whenever international cricket must justify its existence against the earnings available elsewhere.
Players are responding rationally to this economy. A short
career, the possibility of injury and uneven national contracts make franchise
money compelling. Lecturing them about patriotism evades the responsibility of
administrators who have allowed the financial choices to become so unequal.
The deeper question is what happens to international cricket
when representing a country becomes the opportunity players must sacrifice
income to accept.
India’s dominance makes that question especially urgent. The
BCCI can pursue the interests of Indian cricket; that is its institutional
purpose. The ICC must defend a wider constituency. Its credibility depends on
demonstrating that the priorities of its most powerful member encounter
meaningful limits.
Other boards share responsibility. Administrators cannot
applaud every accommodation of concentrated wealth and later lament the
disappearance of their own negotiating power. An international governing body
becomes weak through the accumulated decisions of its members.
Nor should investment in women’s cricket, Associate
development or Olympic participation place governance beyond criticism. These
are valuable ambitions. Their value makes independent scrutiny more necessary:
who receives resources, who obtains meaningful fixtures, and who can influence
the decisions shaping their future?
Cricket’s richness comes from the coexistence of different
traditions and competing ambitions. A Test series in the Caribbean, a
Bangladesh home season and a developing nation’s qualification campaign cannot
all be assessed by their capacity to satisfy the same advertising market.
A genuinely global game must preserve places where
commercial scale does not determine sporting worth.
India now possesses enough influence to help secure that
future—or steadily diminish it. The threat lies in a system that mistakes
Indian financial supremacy for a mandate to organise the entire sport around
Indian commercial interests.
The ICC must protect international windows, sustain
meaningful bilateral competition and make its decisions answerable to the whole
membership.
Otherwise, cricket may discover that its richest nation has
helped build a magnificent enclosure: brilliantly lit, lavishly sponsored, and
increasingly too narrow for the world.
Thank You
Faisal Caesar
