England’s summer had been a series of aftershocks, one crisis tripping over another. The defeat at The Oval was just the latest tremor — another innings collapse, another public inquest. Graham Gooch’s failure to wrench the Ashes from Australia still smouldered in the background, but it was the Fifth Test that exposed just how brittle the edifice had become.
Michael Atherton, the 71st man to captain his country and the sixth from Lancashire, began with optimism that felt more ceremonial than real. Within days, England were not only vanquished by another vast margin, but overshadowed by Ted Dexter’s resignation as chairman of selectors — six months before his term was due to expire. The announcement was greeted not with shock, but with applause, as if a tired actor had finally taken his curtain call.
Selections in the Shadow of Panic
The pre-match days were a shuffle of bodies and policies. Lathwell and Caddick were dropped, McCague’s back gave way, and in came Devon Malcolm, Steve Watkin, and Matthew Maynard — the latter making his first Test appearance since his 1988 debut and subsequent exile for touring South Africa. Then, 48 hours before the toss, and just shy of his 41st birthday, John Emburey was plucked from cricketing semi-retirement when team manager Keith Fletcher finally heeded warnings about a parched pitch that would welcome spin.
The improvisation continued. Jack Russell, long a casualty of the selectors’ batsman-wicketkeeper experiment, was summoned as insurance for the bruised Alec Stewart, only to be dispatched home once Stewart was deemed fit. Watkin and Malcolm were also quietly dropped from the final XI. Australia, by contrast, arrived unaltered, their stability an implicit taunt.
Atherton’s Debut in the Storm
Atherton’s plan was simple in outline and ambitious in nature: win the toss, bat first, and score 450. The first two steps he managed; the last evaporated quickly. He batted with the calm precision of a man who wore captaincy comfortably, his 72 in 192 minutes the lone example of sustained composure in either innings. Yet, when Gooch fell to a Reiffel shooter for 156 for five, England’s spine buckled.
The rescue came, improbably, from Emburey. Slotting in at No. 8, he chiselled 116 runs in alliances with Thorpe, Bicknell, Such, and Ilott, his unbeaten 55 full of improvised strokes that seemed drawn from a garage workbench rather than the MCC coaching manual. His innings delayed, but did not alter, the inevitable. Reiffel’s sixth wicket ended England’s resistance at 321, leaving Atherton with a toothless new-ball pairing (Bicknell and Ilott’s combined Test record: eight for 468) and two off-spinners — one of them convinced his Test days were a memory.
The Waugh Doctrine
By stumps, Australia were 258 for five, still 18 behind but already dictating terms. A dropped stumping by Stewart off Such — Steve Waugh on two, Australia on 80 for four — was the hinge on which the match swung. The Waugh brothers, previously restrained in tandem, built 153 together, Steve grimly anchored, Mark dazzling. Mark’s 137, with 18 fours, was Australia’s tenth Test century of the summer — equalling the Ashes record and eclipsing Bradman’s “Invincibles” tally from 1948.
Atherton, to his credit, worked the field with thought, even consulting Gooch and Stewart. When Mark Waugh finally fell to a trap at backward square leg, Gooch embraced his successor as if passing him a fragment of validation. But the next day, Healy’s counterattack shredded the remains of England’s composure, and dissent crept in — Thorpe flinging the ball in frustration, Stewart celebrating a non-existent wicket. Atherton brushed off the petulance as misplaced enthusiasm, but the cracks in discipline mirrored those in performance.
The Illusion of Resistance
Entering the fourth day at 89 for one, trailing by 43, England still had a thread of hope. Gooch’s early dismissal — bowled round his legs by Warne — frayed it further. Maynard, becalmed and baffled by May’s spin, looked trapped in quicksand. Only Thorpe, batting nearly four hours with unflustered tenacity, and Emburey, reprising his stubbornness, suggested resistance.
Yet once Emburey departed, the collapse was mechanical. Warne and May split the wickets evenly, dismantling England’s innings until Ilott fell in farce — bowled off his backside. Australia’s chase was briefly rattled by losing both openers on 12, but Mark Waugh’s strokeplay against spin rendered the tension cosmetic. By two o’clock, Australia had their 4–0 lead, their 12th win in 18 Tests against England, and were scenting a 5–0 whitewash.
The Young Captain and the Old Order
Atherton had joined an unenviable list — the eighth consecutive England captain to lose his first Test in charge, following Gower, Gatting, Emburey, Cowdrey, Gooch, Lamb, and Stewart. Only Bob Willis, in a different cricketing world, had begun with victory.
When Dexter’s resignation was confirmed mid-match, the young captain faced a battery of cameras and questions, the subtext dripping with intrigue: should he have been told beforehand? Atherton dodged the political trap, promising instead to find young players with “two things — talent and temperament — and then show faith in them.”
It was a statesmanlike exit line, but the match had shown the scale of that task. Faith, in English cricket, was in short supply; temperament even rarer. And the Ashes? Already gone, buried beneath the weight of a summer’s squandered chances.
Thank You
Faisal Caesar



.jpeg)

.jpeg)
.jpeg)



.jpeg)