A Reappraisal of Misbah-ul-Haq’s Captaincy: A Lesson in Leadership and Resilience

If you had asked me a few years ago whether I supported Misbah-ul-Haq’s appointment as captain of Pakistan, my response would have been an emphatic NO. Frankly, Younis Khan has always been my preferred leader. To me, Younis embodied the quintessential Pakistani captain—aggressive, spirited, and brimming with that raw energy which has historically defined the nation’s cricket. By contrast, Misbah’s stoic demeanour, almost reluctant body language, and cautious approach left me unconvinced. He lacked the visible fire that I thought was essential to inspire a team known as much for its brilliance as for its volatility. 

When the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) handed the reins to Misbah, I was deeply sceptical. Pakistan cricket was in a slump, caught in a mire of inconsistency, and in my view, they needed a leader with an indomitable spirit to rally them. Misbah, at that time, did not appear to fit the bill. I feared his approach would drain the spark from a team that thrives on emotional highs. Yet, with the benefit of hindsight, I have realized that my initial assessment was shortsighted - misjudging leadership based on appearances alone is a common, albeit regrettable, mistake. 

Leadership Beyond Appearance: Still Waters Run Deep 

Misbah-ul-Haq’s tenure as captain gradually revealed that leadership comes in many forms. It became clear that his seemingly reserved demeanour concealed a deeper strength - one rooted not in theatrics but in consistency, discipline, and composure. In hindsight, his appointment was precisely what Pakistan cricket needed during a turbulent period. A volatile team calls for stability, and Misbah, in his quiet and unassuming way, provided just that. His captaincy embodied the proverb: “Still waters run deep.” 

Beneath the calm exterior was a man resolute in his mission to rebuild the team, and his leadership became the balm that soothed a historically fractious dressing room. 

Misbah was not just a captain but a "man-manager" par excellence. He succeeded in cultivating a harmonious environment in a team notorious for internal strife. Keeping such a diverse and emotionally charged group united is no small feat, especially when expectations are perpetually high. Misbah's ability to maintain order and foster unity behind closed doors deserves recognition. His leadership may not have fit the traditional mould of Pakistani captains, but in many ways, it was a more sustainable model. 

Defending the Defensive Approach 

While I remain a sceptic of defensive captaincy as a philosophy, Misbah’s pragmatism proved to be precisely what the situation demanded. Pakistan’s vulnerabilities - both on and off the field - called for a captain who could prioritize consolidation over flamboyance. Misbah’s methods, though conservative, provided the team with structure, which had long been missing. Cricket, like life, sometimes demands flexibility; not every game is won with aggression, and Misbah’s more measured approach created a much-needed foundation for stability and long-term success. 

Leading from the Front: A Captain Reborn 

Interestingly, the burden of captaincy did not weigh Misbah down - instead, it galvanized his own performance. His batting, though never dazzling, became a steady source of valuable runs at crucial moments. In Test cricket, where patience and resilience often trump flair, Misbah's methodical accumulation proved invaluable. By leading from the front with the bat, he inspired his teammates, showing that leadership is about setting an example, not just issuing directives. 

In retrospect, I was mistaken in doubting Misbah’s capability to lead. His tenure demonstrated that leadership is not merely about charisma or aggression; it is about knowing when to be firm, when to be flexible, and, most importantly, how to instil belief in those you lead. Pakistan cricket, under Misbah, found a new resolve—a mental clarity that had long been elusive. 

Misbah’s Legacy 

Misbah-ul-Haq’s captaincy serves as a lesson in the deceptive nature of appearances and the importance of adaptive leadership. His approach may not have aligned with traditional expectations, but it was precisely what Pakistan cricket required at that moment in history. Misbah brought stability, cohesion, and professionalism to a team that had often lacked these qualities. And though his tenure might not have been defined by flamboyant tactics, it left a lasting impact - both on the scoreboard and in the spirit of the players he led. 

In the end, I don’t mind admitting I was wrong. Misbah proved that true leadership is not about conforming to expectations but about understanding what your team needs - and delivering exactly that. His story reminds us that leaders are not born from archetypes; they are forged in moments of crisis. And for Pakistan cricket, Misbah-ul-Haq’s captaincy was a moment of quiet triumph.

Thank You

Faisal Caesar  

The Poetry of Chaos: Pakistan’s Dramatic Triumph in Hamilton

The third day at Hamilton began like a symphony building toward an intricate crescendo—calm, composed, and balanced. The pitch remained placid, seemingly promising a day of attrition between bat and ball. Yet, cricket, as always, had other plans. Just when a hard-fought contest seemed poised to unfold, Pakistan reminded the world why they are the sport’s most unpredictable artists. A serene day turned into a storm of chaos, reducing New Zealand from relative comfort to utter disarray in a session that encapsulated Pakistan’s cricketing essence.  

A Fragile Calm  

The Kiwis entered the match as marginal favourites, buoyed by their home advantage and Pakistan’s inconsistency. After being outclassed in their recent tours of Bangladesh and India, New Zealand hoped to reset against an enigmatic Pakistani side. For two days, the script adhered to expectations -  a tight, even contest where batters ground out runs, and bowlers patiently chipped away. But this predictability was destined to be fleeting. As the sun dipped behind the stands on the third day, Pakistan shattered that calm, reminding everyone that no amount of planning or form can tame their wild genius.  

The Collapse Unfolds: A Tale of Panic and Precision  

It wasn’t the terrifying swing of Wasim Akram or the reverse magic of Waqar Younis that triggered New Zealand’s collapse, nor the searing hostility of Mohammad Amir or Mohammad Asif. Instead, it was a trio of bowlers not often associated with magic - Wahab Riaz, Abdur Rehman, and Umar Gul, who orchestrated a collapse so sudden that it left players, fans, and commentators bewildered.  

The first domino fell when Rehman, a spinner who thrives on subtle variations rather than sharp turns, drew Tim McIntosh out of his crease with a teasing delivery. Stumped by Adnan Akmal, the dismissal evoked memories of Asif Mujtaba’s reflex catch off Waqar’s bowling at Wellington in 1993, a single spark that ignited a blaze. And what a blaze it was.  

Wahab Riaz, known more for his aggression in limited-overs cricket, then removed Brendon McCullum, New Zealand’s most explosive batter, shifting the momentum decisively. Rehman followed with the scalp of Martin Guptill, and the pressure intensified. Riaz’s next victim was Jesse Ryder, trapped in front by a venomous inswinger for a golden duck, leaving the Kiwis in turmoil.  

Ross Taylor, the backbone of New Zealand’s middle order, became a casualty of panic—run out after a miscommunication, his dismissal emblematic of the pressure that Riaz and Rehman had cultivated. Kane Williamson, another key figure, was soon undone by Riaz, while Daniel Vettori was pinned lbw by Rehman. What had been a promising 60 for 1 now lay in tatters at 71 for 7. In the blink of an eye, Pakistan had conjured a scenario few could have imagined at the start of the day.  

The Final Blow: Gul Seals the Fate  

If Rehman and Riaz were the architects of New Zealand’s collapse, Umar Gul was the executioner. Bowling with pace, hostility, and precision, Gul wrapped up the tail with ruthless efficiency. By the time the dust settled, New Zealand’s innings had been reduced to rubble, leaving Pakistan with a target of just 19 runs. They chased it down without losing a wicket, completing a victory that seemed improbable just hours earlier.  

The Unwritten Code of Pakistani Cricket  

This victory was more than a triumph on the scoreboard—it was a reminder of the essence of Pakistani cricket, an essence shaped by unpredictability, resilience, and flair. To understand Pakistan’s cricketing DNA is to understand that chaos is not their enemy but their ally. They thrive in moments where structure dissolves, where logic falters, and where only instinct prevails. It is in these moments that unknown names step forward, performing feats that echo those of their illustrious predecessors.  

In the absence of icons like Wasim, Waqar, or Imran, it was the Guls, the Riazs, and the Rehmans who carried the torch. Yet, these names, too, may vanish into the shadows of Pakistan’s cricketing labyrinth, only to be replaced by new talents—bowlers from Rawalpindi, Lahore, or Sialkot—ready to step into the spotlight with the same audacity and brilliance. Pakistan’s cricketing history is a relay of genius, handed down not through tradition but through instinct, unpredictability, and an unyielding refusal to conform.  

A Legacy of the Unthinkable  

Hamilton’s sudden collapse was not just a statistical anomaly; it was a reaffirmation of what makes Pakistan a unique force in world cricket. In an era where data-driven analysis and predictability dominate, Pakistan remains a beautiful outlier—capable of scripting the unthinkable, often when least expected.  

To ban Pakistan from the cricketing arena, as some critics have suggested in moments of frustration, would be to rob the sport of one of its most essential elements - the thrill of the unknown. Without Pakistan, cricket would lose not just a team but an ethos that celebrates chaos, embraces risk, and cherishes the improbable.  

Pakistan’s triumph in Hamilton will be remembered not only for the wickets that fell but for the story it told: a story of how, in the blink of an eye, ordinary players can summon extraordinary performances, transforming games and redefining what is possible. And as long as Pakistan plays cricket, there will always be moments like these moments that remind us why we love the game, in all its beauty and unpredictability.

Thank You

Faisal Caesar