Dunga’s Brazil: A Momentary Respite Amidst Growing Discontent

Carlos Dunga found himself at a critical juncture as Brazil’s head coach, navigating turbulent waters following a tactically underwhelming display against Chile that invited sharp global criticism. The clash against Venezuela, perceived as a relatively straightforward assignment, presented a crucial opportunity to regain lost ground. Fortunately for Dunga, Venezuela's status as underdogs played into Brazil’s hands, allowing the Seleção to seize control early on and secure a vital 3-1 victory.

First-Half Flourish: Willian Shines Bright

Brazil’s start was marked by a sense of urgency, embodying the flair and dominance their fans have come to demand. Willian, arguably the star of the evening, delivered a stellar performance in the opening half, scoring twice to propel Brazil into a commanding position. His sharp movements and clinical finishing revitalized the Brazilian attack, offering glimpses of the creativity and aggression once synonymous with the Seleção. Yet, even as Brazil dictated terms, the artistry and elegance that define their footballing heritage remained elusive.

Second-Half Slump: Old Habits Resurface

The second half, however, painted a different picture. The intensity and precision that marked the first 45 minutes faded, giving way to a lacklustre and disjointed performance. This regression allowed Venezuela to capitalize on one of Brazil’s persistent vulnerabilities: defending set-pieces. The visitors scored a historic goal on Brazilian soil, a moment that not only underscored Brazil’s defensive frailties but also reignited the spectre of unpredictability in Dunga’s tenure.

The tension was palpable as the possibility of squandering their first-half advantage loomed large. Yet, it was the veteran Ricardo Oliveira, at 35 years old, who quelled the nerves. Channelling his wealth of experience, Oliveira delivered a decisive third goal, a moment of redemption for a player often criticized for his perceived parallels with underperformers like Fred and Jô. His strike secured Brazil the much-needed three points and momentarily eased the pressure on Dunga.

Dunga’s Dilemma: Selection and Strategy Under Fire

While the victory buys Dunga time, the cracks in his managerial approach remain glaring. His continued preference for certain players over arguably more deserving options has become a recurring theme. Talented individuals such as Lucas Moura, Alexandre Pato, Lucas Lima, Renato Augusto, and Thiago Silva languish on the fringes, their exclusion raising questions about Dunga’s vision for the team.

Furthermore, this performance, albeit sufficient against a weaker opponent, offers little reassurance against stronger adversaries. The hallmark of a great coach lies in elevating his team’s consistency and delivering results against elite competition. For Dunga, the challenge is not merely survival but restoring Brazil’s footballing identity—a blend of beauty and effectiveness that resonates beyond fleeting victories.

A Long Road Ahead

As the dust settles on this match, the questions surrounding Dunga’s stewardship remain largely unanswered. The win against Venezuela provides a temporary reprieve, but it does little to dispel the concerns about Brazil’s tactical coherence and player management. For the Seleção to truly regain their stature, they must demonstrate similar resolve and dominance against formidable opponents. Only then can Dunga's position as coach be met with genuine acceptance, rather than reluctant tolerance.

Thank You

Faisal Caesar  

A Forgotten Epic: The 1984 Karachi Test Between Pakistan and England

When Pakistan and England meet on the cricket field, the narrative often drifts toward controversies rather than the thrilling encounters that have defined their rivalry. Over the decades, their clashes have been marred by contentious incidents, souring relations between the two cricketing nations. Yet, amidst the turmoil and mistrust, their battles have gifted us some of the sport’s most unforgettable moments. One such forgotten classic was the first Test of England’s 1984 tour to Pakistan, played at Karachi—a gripping tale of resilience, nerves, and cricketing brilliance. 

Setting the Stage: Two Teams, Two Narratives

England arrived in Pakistan in the winter of 1984 on the back of a lacklustre season, having lost a Test series in New Zealand. Led by the formidable Bob Willis, England possessed a strong lineup featuring Ian Botham, David Gower, Allan Lamb, and Mike Gatting. Their record in Pakistan was enviable, having remained unbeaten in the country in 13 previous Tests. 

In contrast, Pakistan was a team in transition, missing their two stalwarts—Imran Khan and Javed Miandad—due to injuries. The captaincy was handed to the elegant Zaheer Abbas, while young talents like Rameez Raja and Saleem Malik were tasked with stepping into big shoes. The bowling responsibilities rested on the experienced Sarfraz Nawaz and the wizardry of leg-spinner Abdul Qadir, with support from unheralded names like Azeem Hafeez and Tauseef Ahmed. 

The Karachi pitch, traditionally friendly for batsmen, hinted at deterioration as the match progressed, making the toss a crucial moment. Willis, wary of his team’s struggle against spin, opted to bat first. 

England’s First Innings: A Tale of Two Halves

England’s opening pair of Christopher Smith and Mike Gatting displayed classic Test-match grit, carefully negotiating the early movement from Sarfraz and Azeem Hafeez. Their watchful approach yielded a solid start, with England reaching 90 for 1 shortly before tea. However, the introduction of Sarfraz’s reverse swing and Qadir’s leg spin triggered a collapse. Sarfraz dismissed Smith and Lamb in quick succession, while Qadir bamboozled Randall with a spinning beauty. England ended the first day precariously placed at 147 for 4. 

The second day saw the Pakistani bowlers tighten their grip. Abdul Qadir and Sarfraz ran riot, dismantling England’s lower order with clinical precision. Qadir’s artistry earned him a five-wicket haul (5 for 74), while Sarfraz’s guile fetched 4 for 42. England was bundled out for a modest 182, a score that belied their promising start. 

Pakistan’s Response: Cook’s Left-Arm Magic

Pakistan’s reply began confidently, with openers Mohsin Khan and Qasim Omar batting fluently. But the introduction of Nick Cook, England’s left-arm spinner, changed the narrative. Cook struck repeatedly, dismantling Pakistan’s top order and leaving them reeling at 105 for 5. Zaheer Abbas, the captain and batting linchpin, fell for a duck, compounding Pakistan’s woes. 

Saleem Malik, however, stood firm amidst the chaos. His assured footwork and calm temperament anchored the innings as he found an unlikely ally in Abdul Qadir. The duo added a vital 75 runs for the seventh wicket, frustrating the English bowlers. Malik’s gritty 74 and Qadir’s valuable 40 guided Pakistan to a crucial lead of 95 runs, with Nick Cook finishing with impressive figures of 6 for 65. 

England’s Second Innings: A Collapse Under Pressure

England’s second innings began on a cautious note but soon descended into disarray. Sarfraz’s reverse swing and Qadir’s variations proved too much for the visitors. Controversial umpiring decisions added to England’s misery, with Allan Lamb and others falling to contentious calls. 

By lunch on the fourth day, England’s lead was a meagre 33 runs with seven wickets down. The tail offered little resistance, and Pakistan dismissed England for 128, leaving themselves a target of just 65 runs to win. 

A Chase to Remember: High Drama in Karachi 

What should have been a straightforward chase turned into a nerve-wracking affair. Nick Cook, enjoying the Test of his life, dismissed Pakistan’s top order in quick succession. Ian Botham’s brilliance in the slips and Norman Cowan’s stunning outfield catch compounded Pakistan’s panic. At 40 for 6, with their unbeaten record at Karachi under threat, Pakistan teetered on the brink of a dramatic collapse. 

Enter Anil Dalpat and Abdul Qadir. The duo steadied the ship, inching Pakistan closer to the target with cautious singles and resolute defence. Even as Qadir fell, Pakistan held their nerve. With just three runs needed, Sarfraz Nawaz edged a boundary to seal a memorable victory, 25 minutes before the day’s close. 

The Legacy of Karachi 1984

This match, Pakistan’s first victory over England in 13 home Tests, remains a forgotten gem in cricket’s annals. It exemplified the drama and unpredictability that make Test cricket the pinnacle of the sport. Yet, as time has passed, the focus has shifted to the controversies that have often overshadowed this historic rivalry. 

As Pakistan and England prepare for their next Test series, one can only hope for encounters that echo the spirit of Karachi 1984—a battle of skill, resilience, and nerves. Let the cricketing world remember such classics, celebrating the timeless beauty of the game over its contentious moments.

Thank You

Faisal Caesar

Brazil's Struggles: A Tactical Dissection of Dunga’s Approach

Brazil’s recent performance against the Copa América champions painted a picture of a team with immense potential, yet marred by tactical missteps and questionable squad management. Missing key players like Neymar, alongside injuries to Philippe Coutinho and Roberto Firmino, undeniably reduced Brazil’s attacking arsenal. However, the Seleção still possessed the talent to challenge even the best teams. The problem, as it has been under Dunga’s tenure, lies not in the absence of skill but in its utilization—or lack thereof. 

A Crisis of Selection and Substitution

Dunga’s decision-making, particularly in team selection and substitutions, left much to be desired. Starting Willian on the right instead of Lucas Moura baffled many. Willian, while a diligent performer, lacks the explosiveness Moura could have brought to the game. Similarly, the substitution of Hulk in the second half was delayed, robbing Brazil of an opportunity to inject fresh energy into a stagnating attack. When Ricardo Oliveira did come on, he brought an immediate spark, creating two opportunities that went begging—a stark reminder of Brazil’s enduring woes with the number nine position. 

The absence of young, agile forwards capable of capitalizing on such chances is glaring. Dunga’s reluctance to experiment with players like Alexandre Pato underscores this issue. Pato, a player with the pace and finishing ability Brazil sorely needs, has been inexplicably overlooked. The same can be said of Thiago Silva in defense, whose exclusion leaves Brazil’s backline vulnerable. Miranda, shaky and inconsistent, has failed to establish a commanding partnership with David Luiz, leaving the defence fragile and error-prone. 

A Static Midfield and Misplaced Roles

Brazil’s midfield remains the weakest link in their setup, with predictability and stagnation defining their play. Oscar, once heralded as a creative force, was anonymous, while Douglas Costa seemed burdened by the expectation to replicate Neymar’s brilliance. Costa, a natural playmaker, was miscast as a goalscorer, which disrupted the fluidity of his partnership with Marcelo on the left flank. 

Among the midfielders, only Luiz Gustavo appeared competent, but he was overburdened in the absence of support from his peers. The late introduction of Lucas Lima highlighted Dunga’s tactical inefficiency. Lima, with his incisive passing and vision, immediately injected life into the midfield but was afforded too little time to make a significant impact. Casemiro, a standout performer at Real Madrid, was another glaring omission. His ability to control the tempo and shield the defence would have been invaluable in this setup. 

The inclusion of players like Elias, who failed to contribute meaningfully, raises questions about selection priorities. With players like Casemiro and Lucas Lima available, why were they not trusted to lead the midfield? 

Defensive Instability and Tactical Naivety

Brazil’s defensive issues are equally concerning. Without a leader like Thiago Silva, the backline lacked structure and cohesion. Miranda’s inability to command the defence was evident, and David Luiz’s adventurous runs forward often left gaps for opponents to exploit. 

These lapses were exacerbated by a lack of midfield cover, forcing defenders like Dani Alves and Marcelo to venture forward to spark attacks. While their attacking instincts are commendable, it left Brazil vulnerable to counterattacks, which players like Eduardo Vargas and Alexis Sánchez capitalized on. 

Dunga’s Pragmatism: A Double-Edged Sword

At the heart of Brazil’s problems is Dunga’s pragmatic approach. While pragmatism can yield results, it often stifles creativity and limits players’ natural expression. This was painfully evident in Brazil’s performance, which lacked the flair and fluidity that once defined their football. 

Dunga must recognize that rigid systems and conservative tactics will only take Brazil so far. Players thrive when given the freedom to express themselves within a clear framework—a balance that the current setup fails to achieve. 

The Path Forward

To restore Brazil’s former glory, Dunga must address these glaring issues: 

1. Selection and Squad Balance

The inclusion of players like Pato, Thiago Silva, and Casemiro is essential. Young, dynamic forwards must be prioritized, and ageing or underperforming players reassessed. 

2. Midfield Revamp

Creativity in midfield is non-negotiable. Players like Lucas Lima and Casemiro need to be central to Brazil’s plans, providing both defensive solidity and attacking impetus. 

3. Tactical Evolution

Dunga must adopt a more progressive mindset, allowing players the freedom to express themselves. A rigid, safety-first approach stifles Brazil’s natural strengths and alienates fans longing for the attacking brilliance of old. 

4. Defensive Stability

 A return to defensive basics, coupled with the inclusion of experienced leaders like Thiago Silva, can restore structure and composure at the back. 

Conclusion

Brazil’s recent struggles are not just about missing key players—they reflect deeper structural and tactical flaws that must be addressed urgently. The Seleção’s rich history and immense talent pool demand a more nuanced and ambitious approach. For Brazil to reclaim their place among football’s elite, Dunga must evolve, or risk being left behind by the modern game.

Thank You

Faisal Caesar

A Cricketing Festival Deferred: Lessons for Bangladesh Cricket

October 2015 was poised to be a month of celebration for cricket in Bangladesh. The much-anticipated two-match Test series between Bangladesh and Australia, scheduled to begin on October 9, had fans buzzing with excitement. Bangladesh, riding high on their exceptional form that year, was set to challenge a new-look Australian side led by Steve Smith. However, this festive anticipation gave way to dismay when Cricket Australia (CA) delayed their team’s departure citing security concerns, eventually leading to the tour's postponement.

The decision by CA sparked intense debate and disappointment among Bangladesh cricket enthusiasts. At the heart of the issue was a security alert issued by Australia’s Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT), which claimed that "militants may be planning to target Australian interests." While such advisories are not uncommon, the specificity of this warning raised eyebrows. Critics, including ESPNcricinfo's Brydon Coverdale, pointed out the absence of similar advisories for neighboring countries, adding to the perception of disproportionate caution.

Context and Concerns

Cricket Australia's approach involved dispatching their security manager, Sean Carroll, to assess the situation on the ground. Meetings with officials from the Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) and various security agencies, including the Directorate General of Forces Intelligence (DGFI), were arranged to ensure comprehensive measures were in place. Yet, the murder of an Italian national in Dhaka during Carroll’s stay added a tragic complication. Although Bangladeshi authorities and Italian officials dismissed the incident as an act of terrorism, the claim of responsibility by a terrorist group amplified CA's apprehensions.

This unfortunate sequence of events led CA to officially postpone the tour on October 1. For a cricket-loving nation like Bangladesh, the announcement was a bitter pill to swallow, especially given the country’s recent track record of successfully hosting high-profile series against Pakistan, India, and South Africa without incident. Players like Hashim Amla and Dale Steyn had openly interacted with fans on Dhaka's streets, a testament to the secure environment provided during those tours.

The Global Reality of Terrorism

Australia's decision, while rooted in legitimate concerns for player safety, underscores a broader issue: the omnipresence of terrorist threats in today's world. No nation is immune. Australia's own history includes incidents like the 1982 bombing of the Israeli consulate in Sydney and the 2014 Sydney hostage crisis. Bangladesh, by comparison, has experienced fewer such incidents, though political unrest in 2013 and 2014 briefly cast a shadow over its stability.

The question arises: should global cricket and other international engagements be held hostage by such threats? While the safety of players and staff is paramount, there is a pressing need to strike a balance between caution and resilience. Otherwise, the very essence of global sportsmanship and cultural exchange risks being eroded.

The Way Forward for Bangladesh Cricket

The postponement of Australia’s tour, though a setback, must serve as a catalyst for introspection and strategic action by the BCB. Here are three crucial steps:

1. Strengthening Diplomatic Ties

The BCB must adopt a proactive approach to fostering stronger relationships with other cricket boards. Bangladesh remains relatively isolated in the international cricketing fraternity, and building alliances is key to gaining trust and support. Collaborative diplomacy can help counteract biases and ensure fair treatment in the global arena.

2. Professionalizing Leadership

Nepotism and incompetence have no place in the administration of a sport that is a national passion. The BCB must prioritize meritocracy, appointing individuals with the expertise and diplomatic acumen necessary to navigate complex international scenarios. Transparent and efficient management will enhance Bangladesh’s credibility on the global stage.

3. Controlling the Narrative

Irresponsible statements in the media can damage the country’s reputation and undermine its cricketing ambitions. The BCB and the Bangladeshi government must ensure that public discourse surrounding cricket remains constructive and measured. Missteps in communication can deepen existing challenges, while thoughtful engagement can bolster confidence in Bangladesh as a host nation.

Resilience Amid Challenges

The postponement of the Australian tour is undoubtedly a blow to Bangladesh cricket. However, it is not an insurmountable one. The nation's cricketing spirit has been tested before and has emerged stronger. With a clear-eyed focus on diplomacy, professionalism, and narrative control, Bangladesh can not only mitigate the impact of this incident but also lay the groundwork for a more resilient and respected cricketing future.

Ultimately, the passion of Bangladesh’s cricket fans, coupled with the team’s undeniable talent, will continue to propel the Tigers forward. For every setback, there is an opportunity to grow. Let this be one such moment.

Thank You
Faisal Caesar

An Open Letter to Cricket Australia: Let Cricket Prevail Over Doubt

Dear Cricket Australia, 

Bangladesh is a nation defined by its resilience, beauty, and unyielding spirit. Its history is rich with tales of struggle and triumph, and its culture boasts an unmatched depth and luxuriance that have captivated travellers and scholars for centuries. From the fine muslin that adorned the noblewomen of imperial Rome to the breathtaking natural landscapes that enchant visitors today, Bangladesh has long been a land of allure, mystery, and vibrancy. 

Through centuries of challenges, Bangladesh has preserved its essence—a symphony of glittering sunshine, tranquil rivers, lush greenery, and the ever-present chorus of birdsong. It is a land that ignites dreams and inspires curiosity, offering an experience unmatched by a few places in the world. Beneath this natural splendour lies a hospitable, peace-loving people whose passion for life is mirrored in their love for sports, particularly cricket. 

Cricket: The Pulse of a Nation 

While kabaddi may be the national game, cricket is the true heartbeat of Bangladesh. It transcends sport; it is a unifying force, a source of hope and pride. Bangladeshi fans, known for their fervour and warmth, are not merely supporters of their national team—they are admirers of the game itself. They cheer not just for their own heroes but for legends from around the world, including your own. 

From Allan Border to Steve Smith, Australian cricketers have inspired generations of Bangladeshi fans, earning deep respect and admiration. The anticipation for the upcoming two-match Test series between Australia and Bangladesh is palpable. It is a chance to witness not only competition but camaraderie—an opportunity to celebrate the spirit of cricket that binds nations together. 

Addressing the Shadows of Concern 

Yet, dark clouds of uncertainty loom over this much-anticipated series. Security concerns, as raised by Cricket Australia, have cast doubt over the tour’s future. While we appreciate your commitment to the safety of your players, we urge you to consider the current reality of Bangladesh. 

The political situation in Bangladesh, including the Chittagong Hill Tracts region, is stable. This area, renowned for its natural beauty, is a must-visit destination, not a danger zone. Bangladesh has consistently demonstrated its capability to host international events with unmatched security and hospitality. The ICC World Twenty20 in 2014 is a testament to this: despite significant challenges, the tournament was a resounding success, underscoring the commitment of the Bangladeshi government and cricket board to ensure the safety of all participants. 

A New Era of Bangladesh Cricket 

Since Australia’s last Test tour in 2006, Bangladesh has evolved into a fearless and competitive cricketing side. This series promises not to be a one-sided affair but a thrilling contest that will enrich the tapestry of Test cricket. For the people of Bangladesh, it is more than just a game—it is a moment of pride, a chance to showcase their nation’s progress on and off the field. 

By cancelling the tour, we risk not only disappointing millions of fans but also undermining the unifying power of cricket. Bangladesh stands ready to host Steve Smith and his men with open arms and an unwavering commitment to their safety. Let us not allow fear to overshadow the joy and unity that cricket brings. 

Let Cricket Be the Victor 

Cricket has the power to transcend boundaries, to unite people in ways few other things can. This tour, if it proceeds, will not merely be a series of matches; it will be a statement of mutual respect and shared love for the game. It will be a testament to the spirit of cricket—that no boundary, political or otherwise, is greater than the bonds it creates. 

We, the cricket-loving people of Bangladesh, eagerly await your arrival. Let cricket prevail, let friendship flourish, and let this series be remembered as a triumph of hope and harmony. 

With warm regards, 

A Cricket Fan from Bangladesh

Thank You

Faisal Caesar