England entered the Champions Trophy to reclaim their former dominance in ODI cricket. After their opening defeat to Australia, they consoled themselves with the belief that it was an unfortunate blip, a result of Lahore’s unpredictable conditions rather than their own shortcomings. However, their hopes were decisively crushed in a dramatic encounter against Afghanistan, whose clinical performance exposed the cracks in England’s game.
The eight-run loss, though narrow on paper, was far from a fluke. It culminated in Afghanistan’s superior strategy, discipline, and execution. More than just a victory, it signified Afghanistan’s rise as a force in world cricket and underscored England’s ongoing decline.
Afghanistan’s Innings: Zadran’s Masterpiece and a Late Surge
A Rocky Start
Afghanistan’s innings began on shaky ground as they found themselves struggling at 37 for three. England’s pace attack, led by Jofra Archer, initially dominated. Archer’s sharp burst accounted for three wickets in his first six overs, leaving Afghanistan with a mountain to climb. At the halfway mark, they had only managed 103 for three, and England seemed to have the upper hand.
Zadran’s Brilliance
Then came the transformation. Ibrahim Zadran played an innings of rare quality—177 runs off 146 balls, blending patience with explosive power. While wickets fell around him, Zadran remained composed, anchoring the innings and shifting gears at the right moments. His shot selection was impeccable, his placement clinical, and his temperament unshaken by England’s early dominance.
Explosive Finish by Azmatullah and Nabi
Zadran found crucial support in captain Hashmatullah Shahidi, who contributed a stabilizing 40, before the game-changing partnerships arrived. Azmatullah Omarzai, fresh from an early failure with the ball, unleashed a counterattack, smashing three sixes in a 31-ball 41.
Then, the veteran Mohammad Nabi joined the charge. His 41 off just 24 balls was an exhibition of fearless hitting. In the 47th over alone, he plundered 23 runs off Joe Root, accelerating Afghanistan’s total past the 300-mark. By the end, the duo had added 111 runs in just 55 balls, turning a solid total into a daunting one—325 for seven.
England’s Chase: A Mixture of Hope and Collapse
Early Wickets and Mounting Pressure
Chasing 326 under lights, England needed a strong start, but their top order crumbled under pressure. Phil Salt departed for 12 after a wild hack against Azmatullah Omarzai, while debutant Jamie Smith misjudged his shot selection and perished for nine, falling to Nabi’s first delivery.
Ben Duckett looked in good touch but was undone by Rashid Khan’s mastery, pinned lbw for 38. Meanwhile, Harry Brook continued his miserable run against spin, gifting a simple return catch to Nabi for 25.
Root’s Lone Resistance
Amid the wreckage, Joe Root stood tall. The former England captain played a masterful innings, crafting 120 from 111 balls. His strokeplay was a blend of precision and artistry, even producing an audacious “pancake-flip” six—an uncharacteristic yet remarkable shot.
For a time, Root and Jos Buttler threatened to turn the tide. Their partnership of 83 runs steadied the chase, keeping England’s hopes alive. But when Buttler fell for 38, top-edging a pull to deep midwicket in the 37th over, the writing was on the wall.
The Final Collapse
With Root left to shoulder the burden, England’s fate hung in delicate balance. But his dismissal in the 46th over, 39 runs short of the target, signalled the beginning of the end. Jamie Overton tried to stage a fightback with a brisk 32, but he too succumbed at the crucial moment.
Jofra Archer’s dismissal left England needing 13 off the final over. The task proved insurmountable, and when Adil Rashid fell off the penultimate delivery, Azmatullah Omarzai completed his five-wicket haul, sealing a historic win for Afghanistan.
England’s Bowling Woes: A Persistent Problem
Archer’s Mixed Day
Jofra Archer’s return to international cricket was a tale of two halves. His initial burst—three wickets for just 22 runs—gave England early control. But as the innings progressed, his impact faded. His last four overs went for 42 runs, mirroring England’s growing struggles in the death overs.
Wood’s Fitness Concerns and Middle-Overs Struggles
Mark Wood, battling a knee injury, was far from his best. His pace lacked its usual venom, and England’s attack suffered as a result. Meanwhile, their inability to take wickets in the middle overs remains a glaring issue. Ever since Liam Plunkett’s departure post-2019, England’s ODI bowling has lacked a cutting edge during this crucial phase.
Lack of Support for Adil Rashid
Adil Rashid was once again England’s most reliable spin option, but the lack of a second attacking spinner left England vulnerable. Afghanistan capitalized on this, ensuring that Rashid alone could not apply sustained pressure.
Afghanistan’s Evolution: No Longer an Underdog Story
This victory was not an upset in the traditional sense. Afghanistan are no longer the plucky underdogs—they are equals. Their batting depth, all-round strength, and fearless approach have turned them into genuine contenders.
Their bowling attack, spearheaded by the guile of Rashid Khan, the versatility of Azmatullah, and the experience of Nabi, is well-rounded and effective. Their fielding, once a weak point, has improved significantly.
With this win, Afghanistan’s semi-final hopes remain alive. They now face Australia in Lahore, a match that will test their credentials further.
England’s Future: A Period of Soul-Searching
For England, this defeat is more than just an early tournament exit. It raises fundamental questions about their ODI identity.
Buttler’s Captaincy Under Scrutiny
Jos Buttler’s future as captain is now under the microscope. His tactical decisions, batting form, and leadership will all be questioned in the aftermath of this failure.
The Batting Core: Aging or Adapting?
Joe Root’s century was a reminder of his class, but beyond him, England’s batting lacked adaptability. The new generation—Salt, Smith, and Brook—have yet to prove they can anchor innings in pressure situations.
Bowling Rebuild Needed
Without a reliable middle-overs enforcer and a fit pace attack, England’s bowling unit looks fragile. The absence of a second frontline spinner also continues to haunt them.
Conclusion: Two Teams, Two Directions
As England depart Lahore for Karachi, their journey has become one of introspection rather than ambition. Their match against South Africa is now a mere formality—a chance to salvage pride but little else.
Afghanistan, on the other hand, march forward with momentum and belief. Their next challenge against Australia will be another step in their remarkable journey—a team once born in refugee camps now challenging the world’s best on cricket’s grandest stages.
This was not just another match. It was a statement. A reminder that Afghanistan belong among the elite and that England, once kings of ODI cricket, are now searching for a way back.
Thank You
Faisal Caesar